The Case of Bear v. Goldilocks

Web Admin - Thursday, February 27, 2014

illinois criminal civil lawyerWhile people often see the story of Goldilocks and the Three Bears as nothing more than a children’s story, it can also act as a simple overview of the legal system. After all, Goldilocks commits a variety of different offenses, both civil and criminal, throughout the story. 

The difference between a civil case and a criminal case is that a civil case involves a dispute between two private parties, the Bears and Goldilocks, while the criminal case involves the state pursuing Goldilocks for her illegal actions. Of course, many of Goldilocks’ actions can give rise to both civil liability and criminal charges.

The Civil Case: Bear v. Goldilocks

The Bears have three claims for which they may be able to sue Goldilocks: trespassing on their land, conversion of the porridge, and conversion of the chair. The Bears can easily show that Goldilocks trespassed on their land, but they will likely not receive any money for doing so, since her act of trespassing did not appear to cause any actual damage on its own. 

As for the claims of conversion, the Bears must show three things: that they owned the porridge and chair, that Goldilocks took some act inconsistent with that ownership, and that their property was damaged by Goldilocks’ acts. Since Goldilocks ate the porridge, and then sat in and broke the chair, the Bears can show that she converted those items and recover their value from Goldilocks.

The Criminal Case: The People v. Goldilocks

The state could also bring criminal charges against Goldilocks for all three of those same actions. These charges would be criminal trespass to land, petty theft of the porridge, and criminal damage to property for breaking the chair. However, the state would not have as easy a case as the Bears did suing for those same actions.

Trespassing is a crime in Illinois punishable by up to a $500 fine and six months in jail, but in order to be guilty of trespassing, a person must enter the land after being warned not to, or they must stay on the land after being told to leave. Unless the Bears had posted a sign warning trespassers, it would only be a civil offense. On the other hand, if Goldilocks had entered the house with a plan to commit a crime, she would be guilty of burglary, a class 2 felony punishable by up to 14 years in prison.

The petty theft of the porridge is an easier case. She clearly steals the porridge by eating it, and in Illinois the seriousness of the theft is determined by the value of the item. Since the porridge was probably worth less than $500, it would be petty theft, a class A misdemeanor punishable by up to a $2500 fine and one year in prison.

The state could also press charges against her for criminal damage to property for her breaking the chair, but this would likely fail. In Illinois, a person must knowingly damage the property to be guilty of the criminal offense. Because Goldilocks did not know she would break the chair if she sat in it, that charge would probably fail.

If you have recently found yourself involved with criminal charges or civil litigation, contact an attorney today. A Rolling Meadows criminal defense or civil litigation attorney can put their knowledge and legal experience to work for you. Our team serves clients across the northwest suburbs, in areas such as Schaumburg, Palatine, Barrington, and Inverness.

About the Author: Founding partner of Drost, Gilbert, Andrew & Apicella, LLC, Colin Gilbert, received his J.D. from Chicago-Kent College of law in 2005. Colin argues cases across many practice areas including criminal defense, collections, real estate law, and corporate law. He is involved in his local Illinois community as an active member of the DuPage County Bar Association, Northwest Suburban Bar Association, and the Arlington Heights Chamber of Commerce. In 2012, Colin was nominated for 2012 Business Leader of the Year by the Chamber.

Recent Posts


blood alcohol content Palatine construction attorney murder defense Self-Directed IRA Accounts pet bites Buffalo Grove personal injury lawyer Deer Park accident attorney Arlington Heights car crash attorneys car crash injuries fatal car accidents Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyer personal injury law firm Rolling Meadows employment law attorney Barrington estate planning lawyer Schaumburg estate attorney Chicago biking tips mortgage Schaumburg corporate attorney Illinois medical malpractice lawyers Chicago will attorney, social media platforms, Illinois estate planning lawyer, preventing accidents cell phone accidents estate planning lawyer Illinois insurance disputes license suspension swimming pools traffic violations defense Illinois job attorney trauma after an accident gift taxes sole proprietorship Illinois business litigation deed transfer digital assets small business motorcycle accident lawyer Kenilworth estate planning lawyer crossover accidents traffic offenses living wills DUI penalities drug crimes life insurance policy Rolling Meadows accident lawyer sexual harassment LLCs living trust Colin H. Gilbert health insurance dispute Schaumburg injury lawyer Des Plaines drug crimes lawyer real estate contract insurance agent negligence Schaumburg car accident attorney Illinois bicycle safety foreclosure rollover accidents Schaumburg medical malpractice lawyer Crystal Lake bike accident lawyer Barrington litigation attorney wrongful termination, employment law, whistleblower protections, Illinois employment laws, discrimination in the workplace unfunded trust DMV Schaumburg estate planning lawyer reckless homicide insurance dispute, insurance dispute lawyers, insurance claim denial, insurance claim delays, Rolling Meadows insurance dispute attorneys automated cars Illinois Smoke Detector Act homestead rights loopholes Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorney Inverness real estate attorney IRS pedestrian accident boating DUI rent to own real estate contracts residential real estate compensatory time wills Illinois Probate Act of 1975 Deer Park traffic accident attorney Legal Info car accident lawyer car accidents trusts Illinois DUI attorney Rolling Meadows boating crash lawyer Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorneys Inverness probate lawyer employment contract personal injury attorney jet ski accidents condo Chicago insurance law firm creditors healthcare claims Chicago trucking accident attorney texting and driving breathalyzer test probate fees Family Medical Leave Act Illinois traffic accident lawyer startup company Rolling Meadows personal injury attorney trucking accidents Rolling Meadows insurance attorney PTSD meal breaks irrevocable trust rumble strips TBI employment law Illinois motorcycle accident lawyer Rolling Meadows insurance lawyer installment contracts Illinois rollover accident lawyers Illinois corporate lawyer commercial leases construction accidents, personal injury, wrongful death, Arlington Heights personal injury attorneys, workers' compensation mass shooting Illinois workplace lawyer Illinois Human Rights Act Arlington Heights tax lawyer federal crimes denied insurance claims digital assets, digital fiduciary, estate planning, digital content, Long Grove estate planning lawyers Schaumburg criminal attorney revenge porn Arlington Heights traffic attorney Illinois real estate lawyer car crashes Des Plaines insurance attorney defective products lawyer golf accidents Illinois law Joliet general practice lawyers surgical mistakes BAC license personal injury digital evidence foreclosed rental property Illinois driving without license Illinois trusts attorney clemency Barrington employment attorney Rolling Meadows probate lawyer murder charges construction contracts Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorneys Illinois car accident attorney nursing home negligence civil litigation attorney insurance claim delay independent contractor corporate law drug crime holiday statistics Rolling Meadows criminal lawyer Mount Prospect real estate lawyer expungement Illinois personal injury field sobriety test Chicago will attorney uninsured motorist Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act Barrington estate planning attorney Illinois collections attorney Illinois personal injury attorney Illinois medical malpractice claim Colin Gilbert Employment Discrimination Law Home Sale Contingencies Palatine employment attorney criminal Long Grove estate planning attorney Des Plaines personal injury lawyer Buffalo Grove car accident lawyer Barrington business law firm condo association Schaumburg insurance lawyers workers compensation insurance claim Illinois business law atorneys dog bites real estate attorneys Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act Crystal Lake car accident lawyer Illinois attorney food poisoning traffic laws Buffalo Grove criminal defense lawyer IRA trust transfer jet ski low-ball insurance settlement elder abuse BAIID ACA Arlington Heights insurance attorney workers compensation benefits medical malpractice Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyers Deer Park criminal attorney Rolling Meadows real estate attorney Crystal Lake criminal defense attorney Illinois defective products attorney Des Plaines criminal attorney Riverwoods estate planning lawyer products liability driving right to work pedestrian injuries, pedestrian fatality Barrington drug crime attorney Palatine traffic lawyer Illinois employment attorneys spinal cord injuries medical marijuana wills and trusts Des Plaines medical malpractice attorney Palatine real estate lawyer Palatine business attorney estate attorney Illinois personal injury lawyer workplace sexual harassment Rolling Meadows criminal attorney no contest clauses Palatine law firm Illinois lawyer vacation home fines Des Plaines preventable medical errors head on collisions Arlington Heights employment law attorneys Inverness traffic law firm probate process Illinois business lawyer insurance denials Illinois speeding lawyer medical research digital information Arlington Heights personal injury lawyer in terrorem provision defective products boating under the influence license revocation probate IRELA employment law, Illinois employment laws Arlington Heights employment attorney back injuries Palatine estate planning lawyer Inverness accident lawyer Crystal Lake employment attorney car accident criminal record attorney fees Rolling Meadows Attorney blended families special needs trust Barrington boating accident attorney Illinois estate planning law firm Des Plaines accident attorney Crystal Lake insurance lawyer rollover car crashes Arlington Heights estate planning attorney Des Plaines Traffic Lawyer construction accidents Palatine civil litigation lawyer Illinois workers compensation attorney denied insurance claim Illinois Transfer on Death Instrument rest breaks Crystal Lake personal injury attorney Palatine employment lawyer Arlington Heights medical malpractice lawyer senior citizens Palatine traffic accidents Inverness injury lawyer controlled substance Illinois jet ski accident lawyer Policy Cancellation Schaumburg elder law lawyer estate planning, death tax, succession plans, business estate plans, Barrington estate planning lawyers Illinois medical malpractice attorney Rolling Meadows medical malpractice lawyers employees Barrington criminal lawyer Barrington medical malpractice lawyers Des Plaines motorcycle accident attorney eluding a police officer involuntary manslaughter Inverness elder law lawyer agent underinsured motorist Chicago corporate attorney Arlington Heights pedestrian accidents hands free device vacation home Buffalo Grove medical malpractice lawyers guardianship attorney motorcycle accident Barrington Traffic Lawyer Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers, insurance dispute Illinois will lawyer unpaid assessment Whistleblower Claims insurance adjusters medical malpractice claims Landlord Tenant Ordinance suspended license Arlington Heights lawyer Arlington Heights injury attorney Des Plaines DUI attorney Palatine workers compensation lawyer consent to a search social media after death Schaumburg insurance claims Rolling Meadows drug defense attorney speeding Palatine probate lawyer Rolling Meadows tax attorney criminal defense Des Plaines personal injury lawyers Chicago attorney Inverness real estate lawyer Palatine punch death BUI Illinois LLC creation sexual images Illinois insurance dispute lawyers federal regulations for LLCs Buffalo Grove employment lawyer Illinois home inspection Illinois criminal defense attorney life insurance lawyer underage DUI Buffalo Grove insurance claim dispute lawyers privacy laws Illinois small business traffic violations subcontractor Long Grove estate planning attorneys manufacturing Barrington criminal defense lawyer slip and fall Des Plaines civil attorney Buffalo Grove probate lawyer Illinois civil litigation lawyer car crash Deer Park workers compensation lawyer DGAA insurance claim dispute fiduciary rule Des Plaines pet law attorney product liability Inverness civil lawyer Illinois trucking safety digital media accounts, estate planning, Arlington Heights estate planning attorney, estate planning medication errors healthcare estate planning for college students probate claims Chicago estate planning college kids Schaumburg real estate lawyer Schaumburg criminal law attorney Long Grove wills and trusts attorneys liability claims pedestrian accidents IRA benefits life insurance claims employment contract, employment law, employment at-will, Deer Park employment law attorneys, contract, Fourth of July Palatine injury attorney Illinois wrongful termination lawyer estate planning, digital assets, Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, Illinois digital assets, Illinois estate planning, work unions Inverness DUI lawyer Rolling Meadows employment attorney real estate closing underfunded trust severance agreements Buffalo Grove traffic attorney Chicago car accident lawyer Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyers Palatine insurance lawyer South Barrington real estate lawyer spinal cord injury personal injury, auto accident injuries, delayed injuries, serious injuries, Des Plaines personal injury attorneys DUI caregiver Illinois wills and trusts appealing an insurance claim POA job lawyers brain injury minimum wage hit and run accident truck collisions gift tax exemption, estate planning, estate planning strategies, Illinois estate planning, South Barrington estate planning attorneys real estate deadly crashes insurance agents employee rights Arlington Heights Attorney Home Remodeling Repair Act drugs Rolling Meadows estate planning attorney Rolling Meadows litigation lawyer forming a corporation in Illinois Illinois traffic ticket lawyer Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers Crystal Lake accident attorney Inverness estate planning lawyer Palatine elder law attorney Illinois construction accident attorney car accident lawyers cell phone insurance claim denials Illinois tax attorney personal injury claim financial advisors Barrington personal injury lawyer Barrington personal injury attorney DUI defense privacy denial of life insurance Chicago estate planning lawyer Palatine personal injury lawyer Illinois employment law attorney Retaliatory Discharge Buffalo Grove corporate attorney fault based insurance dealing with problem employees Barrington real estate lawyer texting while driving taxes Thanksgiving Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyers wage theft Buffalo Grove traffic lawyers Illinois wills and trusts attorneys pizza emoji Schaumburg wrongful death attorney Mount Prospect wills and trusts lawyers employee misclassification Schaumburg personal injury lawyer cell phone tower data Illinois employee rights attorney. personal injury accidents Chicago lawyer Illinois insurance lawyer Crystal Lake medical malpractice lawyer Rolling Meadows DUI lawyer Illinois traffic laws Illinois pedestrian accident attorney Illinois red light cameras drug possession bicycle dooring accidents capital gains tax Barrington employment law attorney first degree murder Kenilworth estate planning attorneys child safety liability Deer Park real estate law firm Food and Drug Administration's Food Safety Modernization Act Deer Park personal injury lawyer traffic crimes marijuana accidental death benefits Barrington injury attorney slip and fall accidents real estate zoning Buffalo Grove real estate attorney Palatine civil attorney Do Not Resuscitate license reinstatement fiduciary rule delay Crystal Lake civil litigation lawyer Palatine Attorney drunk driving statistics workers comp contracts employment attorney power of attorney for healthcare problem employees Arlington Heights car accident lawyer Rolling Meadows car accident lawyers Chicago traffic lawyer elder law Palatine drug lawyer traumatic brain injuries Crystal Lake employment lawyer new real estate form Illinois personal injury lawyers Des Plaines real estate lawyer Illinois traffic attorney School Visitation Rights Act bad faith insurance claims Illinois insurance attorney Attorney Ken Apicella home inspection lawyer Crystal Lake estate planning lawyer tax attorney Inverness personal injury attorney Exclusions traffic deaths Illinois employment law firm Rolling Meadows corporate lawyer Des Plaines collections attorney Arlington Heights trucking lawyer Illinois real estate Rolling Meadows traffic attorney Illinois employment lawyer insurance denial appeals distracted driving accident victims Schaumburg employment law attorneys dynasty trusts Super Mario Schaumburg civil litigation attorney auto accidents Palatine employment law lawyer Liquor Control Act Crystal Lake traffic lawyer institutional trustee advance healthcare directive dram shop law DNR operating agreements Detainer Actions Crystal Lake pet attorney trucking accident lawyers Chicago insurance claim attorneys insurance dispute attorney comp time Mount Prospect elder law attorney premises liability Des Plaines drug lawyer Schaumburg estate planning attorney medical malpractice compensation trench injuries Transfer on Death Instrument Deer Park traffic lawyer Deer Park medical malpractice attorney pet law Arlington Heights Traffic Lawyer insurance attorney breach of contract Schaumburg Attorney Buffalo Grove law firm Illinois employment laws probate lawyer personal injury lawyer Crystal Lake employment law attorney Long Grove real estate lawyer Long Grove real estate attorney insurance claim dispute attorney owner responsibility pregnant women ken apicella investment property Deer Park motorcycle accident lawyer civil litigation paid sick leave Palatine corporate attorney traumatic brain injury insurance disputes pay when paid contract Chicago employment lawyer Des Plaines real estate attorney landlord hiring employees Rolling Meadows Traffic Lawyer Crystal Lake tax lawyer unauthorized overtime civil rights violation Barrington workers compensation attorney traffic accidents Crystal Lake business law attorneys changes to mortgage law real estate leasing Crystal Lake law firm Des Plaines tax law firm drunk driving Arlington Heights criminal lawyer Illinois boating accident lawyer Illinois estate planning attorney personal injury claims ObamaCare employment law, meal breaks, rest breaks, hotel employees, Des Plaines employment law attorneys Schaumburg personal injury lawyers employment lawyer Illinois insurance claim attorney Crystal Lake personal injury lawyer Rolling Meadows traffic law firm commercial leasing marijuana crimes attorney internet commercial real estate distracted driving accidents drug crimes lawyer Illinois insurance claims lawyers Inverness insurance attorney filing a medical malpractice claim overtime pay real estate attorney Schaumburg construction accident lawyer liens Rolling Meadows marijuana attorney Palatine trusts lawyer wrongful termination Illinois mortgages FSLA Illinois elder law attorney Arlington Heights personal injury attorney estate tax Crystal Lake car accident attorney icy parking lots Schaumburg drug defense lawyer Palatine criminal defense lawyer Inverness corporate attorney whistleblower protections Illinois living will criminal law Des Plaines claims law firm Arlington Heights real estate lawyer Mt Prospect Attorney modern family estate planning life insurance Crystal lake insurance dispute attorney Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyer probate claims process estate plan Barrington civil litigation attorney Deer Park employment law attorney Barrington Illinois estate planning lawyer Crystal Lake will lawyer employee discrimination bicycle accidents Arlington Heights accident attorney Illinois probate lawyer medical malpractice, missed diagnosis, delayed diagnosis, medical mistake, Deer Creek medical malpractice lawyers car collision Illinois workplace discrimination attorney insurance disputes, Illinois insurance disputes, Illinois insurance dispute attorneys, denied insurance claims, Arlington Heights insurance dispute attorneys Illinois injury lawyer Long Grove estate planning real estate lawyer Jay Andrew pain and suffering insurance claim denial Schaumburg employment attorney bike accident loss of consortium unpaid overtime Buffalo Grove injury lawyer Forcible Entry Rolling Meadows business lawyer Illinois Sales Representative Act DUI attorney FMLA living trust vs will overtime violations Schaumburg personal injury attorney income distribution deducation Fair Labor Standards Act Arlington Heights TBI attorney Illinois medical malpractice case Chicago employment attorney disability benefits CAM pedestrian-automobile accident trust payments Crystal Lake traffic attorney anesthesia errors murder Barrington employment law firm Crystal Lake medical malpractice law firm Illinois employment law attorneys Des Plaines personal injury attorney Barrington attorney GM ignition switches caretaker rights Kenilworth estate planning attorney Palatine corporate law attorneys Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyer Class A misdemeanor Des Plaines injury law firm Illinois employment law natural gas explosion Illinois estate planning Illinois registered agent Crystal Lake pedestrian accident lawyer comparative negligence landlord tenant law South Barrington real estate attorney insurance negligence Schaumburg probate attorney Illinois traffic attorneys Schaumburg traffic lawyer trustee natural gas boating accidents insurance dispute traffic tickets Buffalo Grove personal injury attorney power of attorney Affordable Care Act Illinois pet lawyer estate planning trusts Crystal Lake injury attorney Rolling Meadows llinois Real Estate Lawyers Association Illinois workers compensation lawyer living trust benefits Rolling Meadows employment law attorneys Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission estate planning attorney Deer Park DUI lawyer wrongful death