Illinois Supreme Court to Consider Negligent Credentialing Case

Web Admin - Monday, February 16, 2015

Illinois Negligent Credentialing, medical malpractice lawyerThe relationship between doctors and hospitals is a complex one. Most people assume that the doctors work for or are partners in the hospital. While some hospitals choose to employ their doctors, it is much more common for the doctors to be independent contractors. The hospitals give the doctors the right to admit patients to the hospital and use their facilities, a decision known as “credentialing.”

Yet, hospitals cannot simply give privileges to whomever they want. The law imposes a duty on hospitals to exercise reasonable care in managing their facilities in order to protect patients. Failure to do so can see the hospital held liable for negligent credentialing.

What Is Negligent Credentialing?

Negligent credentialing occurs when a hospital allows a physician to use their facilities despite that physician’s lack of qualifications. Illinois law requires a plaintiff to prove three things in order to prevail on a negligent credentialing claim:

  1. 1. The hospital breached its duty of care by improperly granting staff privileges to an unqualified physician;
  2. 2. The physician breached the medical standard of care by providing medically negligent treatment in conjunction with their negligently awarded privileges; and
  3. 3. The awarding of the privileges was the proximate cause of the plaintiff’s injuries, meaning that the direct cause of the injuries was the fact that the hospital negligently granted staff privileges to the doctor.

One of the difficulties of winning on a negligent credentialing claim is proving that first element. This requires evidence of what the hospital knew when they credentialed the physician and how thorough their procedures were. The Illinois Supreme Court recently took a case to determine whether plaintiffs in a lawsuit may have access to those records, Klaine v. Southern Hospital Services.

Klaine v. Southern Illinois Hospital Services

The issue in Klaine arises from a colon surgery gone wrong. The plaintiff wanted to pursue a negligent credentialing claim against the hospital, and as part of discovery process the plaintiff requested information about the surgeon’s credentialing process, such as his work history, prior insurance claims against him, and recommendations about his credentialing by the hospital staff. The hospital resisted, citing an Illinois law requiring that a physician’s application for staff privileges be kept “confidential.” The appeals court decided that there was a difference between general confidentiality rules and “privilege,” the special, heightened form of confidentiality that protects things from disclosure during a lawsuit. The Supreme Court will now take the case on to determine if the appeals court was correct in that determination.

The landscape of medical malpractice law is constantly changing. If you have been injured by a physician’s negligence and want to learn more about your options, contact a Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorney at Drost, Gilbert, Andrew & Apicella, LLC today. Our firm helps injured patients all across the northwest suburbs, including in towns like Inverness, Palatine, and Schaumburg.

Ken ApicellaAbout the Author: Attorney Ken Apicella is a founding partner of DGAA focusing in the areas of personal injury, employment, insurance coverage disputes, and civil litigation. Ken earned his J.D. from DePaul University College of Law in 1999. He has been named a SuperLawyers Rising Star and a Forty Illinois Attorneys Under Forty to Watch. Ken has written and lectured for the Illinois Institute for Continuing Legal Education and regularly serves as a moderator at Northwest Suburban Bar Association's Continuing Legal Education seminars.

High Amounts of Preventable Mistakes During Surgery

Web Admin - Wednesday, August 06, 2014

mistakes during surgery medical malpracticePeople routinely place their lives in the hands of medical professionals like surgeons, trusting that they will be careful and responsible. At the same time, people understand that accidents do happen. Surgery can be a difficult process, and there are some complications, like infections, that may occur even if the doctors do everything right. Still, there are certain surgical mistakes that medical professionals universally agree should never occur.

Generally speaking, these “never events” include leaving surgical implements in a patient, performing operations on the wrong site, performing the wrong type of operation, and performing the surgery on the wrong patient. Despite this universal agreement that such completely preventable mistakes should never happen, a study from Johns Hopkins University reveals that surgeons make these sorts of errors with startling regularity.

The Johns Hopkins Study

The study analyzed data that researchers gleaned from the National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB), a database of medical malpractice claims. The law requires hospitals to report preventable surgical errors that lead to legal settlements or judgments against the hospital to the NPDB. This makes the NPDB a repository of data on never events.

The researchers used data from the NPDB and extrapolated out total error rates based on the thousands of medical malpractice judgments and settlements over the last 20 years. They estimate that there are over 4,000 preventable surgical errors in the U.S. every year. These sorts of errors tend to result in a patient's death approximately 6.6 percent of the time, with another 32.9 percent of patients suffering a permanent injury from the never event.

Additionally, the researchers analyzed the patterns of surgeons who make these sorts of mistakes. For instance, they found that surgeons between the ages of 40 and 49 accounted for over one in every three mistakes and that over 10 percent of doctors had been implicated in more than one never event.

Possible Precautions

Fortunately, there are a variety of precautions that hospitals can take to ensure that these sorts of preventable errors do not occur. For instance, some hospitals have specific protocols in place to inventory surgical implements like towels and sponges before and after a surgery to ensure that the doctors leave nothing behind inside the patient.

Beyond that, many hospitals also use special review procedures at the start of a surgery, ensuring that the patient's records for the surgery match the patient on whom the doctor is about to operate. Additionally, practitioners can also use permanent marker to label the operation site. This can help prevent surgeons from operating in the wrong place or operating on the wrong patient.

If you or one of your loved ones has recently been the victim of a surgical error or other medical mistake, contact a skilled Illinois medical malpractice attorney. Our firm represents injured patients in many different northwest suburban towns, including Schaumburg, Arlington Heights, and Crystal Lake.

About the Author: Attorney Ken Apicella is a founding partner of DGAA focusing in the areas of personal injury, employment, insurance coverage disputes, and civil litigation. Ken earned his J.D. from DePaul University College of Law in 1999. He has been named a SuperLawyers Rising Star and a Forty Illinois Attorneys Under Forty to Watch. Ken has written and lectured for the Illinois Institute for Continuing Legal Education and regularly serves as a moderator at Northwest Suburban Bar Association's Continuing Legal Education seminars.

Recent Posts


Illinois LLC creation capital gains tax Crystal Lake employment law attorney Colin H. Gilbert food poisoning Inverness corporate attorney construction accidents, personal injury, wrongful death, Arlington Heights personal injury attorneys, workers' compensation hit and run accident Long Grove real estate lawyer filing a medical malpractice claim Arlington Heights criminal lawyer auto accidents Rolling Meadows drug defense attorney traffic offenses bicycle accidents insurance denials Barrington personal injury attorney Des Plaines insurance attorney wills and trusts Palatine personal injury lawyer pregnant women Barrington criminal defense lawyer Arlington Heights injury attorney employment law, Illinois employment laws Policy Cancellation car crash injuries Des Plaines real estate attorney fiduciary rule traffic tickets medical malpractice claims corporate law Arlington Heights TBI attorney marijuana new real estate form Illinois corporate lawyer Rolling Meadows DUI lawyer personal injury claims motorcycle accident lawyer creditors pedestrian accident School Visitation Rights Act Crystal Lake employment lawyer jet ski Illinois jet ski accident lawyer Rolling Meadows accident lawyer Deer Park motorcycle accident lawyer Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyer Illinois defective products attorney Illinois job attorney car crashes Deer Park workers compensation lawyer bicycle dooring accidents Illinois employee rights attorney. Inverness elder law lawyer Rolling Meadows insurance lawyer Buffalo Grove car accident lawyer Des Plaines insurance claim denials Crystal Lake pedestrian accident lawyer cell phone DMV wrongful death Barrington Illinois estate planning lawyer advance healthcare directive Schaumburg traffic lawyer Schaumburg criminal law attorney Arlington Heights tax lawyer truck collisions Schaumburg personal injury lawyers speeding real estate zoning Palatine insurance lawyer attorney fees Illinois estate planning law firm construction contracts Illinois workplace lawyer employment attorney Barrington civil litigation attorney boating accidents Illinois employment law healthcare commercial leases Arlington Heights traffic attorney Crystal Lake criminal defense attorney comparative negligence loopholes Rolling Meadows probate lawyer Crystal Lake bike accident lawyer digital evidence Illinois tax attorney Buffalo Grove traffic attorney Illinois living will civil rights violation car collision DGAA insurance agent negligence Illinois personal injury lawyers Inverness DUI lawyer bad faith insurance claims Barrington litigation attorney small business Barrington estate planning attorney deed transfer sexual images insurance claim Crystal Lake tax lawyer insurance attorney Des Plaines personal injury lawyers Palatine Attorney Illinois Human Rights Act Illinois wills and trusts attorneys Deer Park DUI lawyer Des Plaines drug lawyer pet law Des Plaines pet law attorney Illinois construction accident attorney criminal record Illinois pet lawyer Des Plaines claims law firm loss of consortium landlord tenant law owner responsibility startup company medical research Illinois probate lawyer modern family estate planning drug crimes lawyer Rolling Meadows traffic law firm defective products lawyer first degree murder Long Grove real estate attorney federal crimes Super Mario Illinois boating accident lawyer Inverness personal injury attorney Retaliatory Discharge personal injury claim Illinois personal injury attorney Exclusions Buffalo Grove real estate attorney eluding a police officer estate tax boating DUI Illinois trusts attorney drunk driving Inverness real estate attorney Rolling Meadows Palatine law firm dram shop law Crystal Lake accident attorney Barrington drug crime attorney pedestrian accidents home inspection lawyer Chicago employment lawyer criminal law revenge porn Arlington Heights pedestrian accidents life insurance Landlord Tenant Ordinance texting and driving life insurance claims estate planning lawyer independent contractor Palatine injury attorney Arlington Heights estate planning attorney car crash Schaumburg criminal attorney consent to a search Whistleblower Claims Illinois mortgages Illinois workplace discrimination attorney IRA trust transfer defective products denial of life insurance icy parking lots Illinois elder law attorney medical marijuana paid sick leave Illinois collections attorney pizza emoji Chicago employment attorney vacation home IRA benefits drug crimes Crystal Lake personal injury attorney Schaumburg wrongful death attorney Schaumburg insurance lawyers Des Plaines accident attorney rent to own real estate contracts golf accidents probate claims process real estate Arlington Heights car crash attorneys Schaumburg personal injury lawyer Food and Drug Administration's Food Safety Modernization Act Self-Directed IRA Accounts living wills Fourth of July estate planning privacy homestead rights estate planning attorney Deer Park criminal attorney Palatine business attorney personal injury attorney pay when paid contract Arlington Heights accident attorney Long Grove estate planning attorney wrongful termination car accidents Illinois rollover accident lawyers Illinois medical malpractice case changes to mortgage law employment lawyer healthcare claims Kenilworth estate planning lawyer Illinois Sales Representative Act denied insurance claim Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorney Schaumburg medical malpractice lawyer underage DUI Inverness accident lawyer Crystal Lake car accident lawyer employment contract, employment law, employment at-will, Deer Park employment law attorneys, contract, CAM Illinois traffic attorney Do Not Resuscitate living trust benefits Deer Park real estate law firm insurance claim delay Palatine elder law attorney health insurance dispute dog bites Crystal lake insurance dispute attorney jet ski accidents underinsured motorist Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyer spinal cord injury trusts ACA Long Grove wills and trusts attorneys reckless homicide traffic violations car accident lawyer Arlington Heights Traffic Lawyer Illinois employment lawyer real estate contract Schaumburg construction accident lawyer distracted driving accidents Illinois bicycle safety Jay Andrew Riverwoods estate planning lawyer insurance claim denial hands free device college kids Palatine corporate attorney Home Sale Contingencies Kenilworth estate planning attorney Arlington Heights medical malpractice lawyer Illinois insurance attorney underfunded trust employment law, meal breaks, rest breaks, hotel employees, Des Plaines employment law attorneys residential real estate Des Plaines Traffic Lawyer Illinois traffic ticket lawyer drunk driving statistics DNR Arlington Heights personal injury lawyer Legal Info criminal slip and fall sole proprietorship South Barrington real estate lawyer meal breaks traumatic brain injuries TBI crossover accidents Palatine corporate law attorneys living trust vs will Palatine civil litigation lawyer digital assets, digital fiduciary, estate planning, digital content, Long Grove estate planning lawyers commercial real estate Inverness traffic law firm insurance dispute attorney Inverness civil lawyer field sobriety test insurance adjusters construction accidents Palatine civil attorney drugs probate fees Illinois registered agent elder law Illinois traffic laws pedestrian-automobile accident distracted driving accident victims trustee Barrington business law firm Crystal Lake traffic attorney Illinois real estate lawyer Illinois motorcycle accident lawyer Illinois personal injury lawyer Schaumburg probate attorney Des Plaines personal injury attorney Crystal Lake will lawyer Palatine employment lawyer Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyers Crystal Lake injury attorney Palatine probate lawyer surgical mistakes Rolling Meadows employment attorney uninsured motorist Crystal Lake personal injury lawyer Rolling Meadows criminal attorney dealing with problem employees Palatine criminal defense lawyer Palatine employment attorney bike accident Rolling Meadows traffic attorney Long Grove estate planning fatal car accidents Schaumburg elder law lawyer severance agreements power of attorney for healthcare Des Plaines injury law firm Des Plaines real estate lawyer rest breaks wage theft real estate attorneys Palatine traffic accidents Barrington estate planning lawyer traffic crimes Crystal Lake insurance lawyer estate planning trusts Arlington Heights employment attorney premises liability natural gas sexual harassment Rolling Meadows insurance attorney Employment Discrimination Law rollover car crashes Transfer on Death Instrument Illinois Detainer Actions personal injury accidents Schaumburg personal injury attorney Schaumburg civil litigation attorney trucking accident lawyers Illinois Probate Act of 1975 gift tax exemption, estate planning, estate planning strategies, Illinois estate planning, South Barrington estate planning attorneys Palatine construction attorney Crystal Lake business law attorneys Palatine workers compensation lawyer Chicago trucking accident attorney personal injury Deer Park accident attorney estate planning, digital assets, Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, Illinois digital assets, Illinois estate planning, Crystal Lake civil litigation lawyer Inverness injury lawyer Rolling Meadows medical malpractice lawyers Schaumburg injury lawyer Rolling Meadows car accident lawyers comp time employees estate plan mortgage Buffalo Grove injury lawyer Deer Park medical malpractice attorney South Barrington real estate attorney foreclosed rental property license revocation Liquor Control Act Illinois injury lawyer Chicago insurance law firm appealing an insurance claim drug crime fiduciary rule delay POA traffic accidents Crystal Lake car accident attorney Rolling Meadows employment law attorney Schaumburg estate attorney Chicago corporate attorney mass shooting child safety insurance claims Chicago biking tips real estate leasing subcontractor Chicago will attorney estate attorney irrevocable trust Illinois Smoke Detector Act Barrington workers compensation attorney Forcible Entry Chicago traffic lawyer Buffalo Grove traffic lawyers Arlington Heights car accident lawyer estate planning for college students Mount Prospect wills and trusts lawyers investment property pain and suffering Rolling Meadows litigation lawyer ObamaCare Schaumburg drug defense lawyer Buffalo Grove personal injury attorney traffic violations defense elder abuse Deer Park traffic lawyer business litigation license suspension Fair Labor Standards Act Arlington Heights Attorney Barrington Traffic Lawyer power of attorney Barrington real estate lawyer workers comp digital assets Des Plaines tax law firm real estate lawyer civil litigation attorney medical malpractice compensation Illinois law breach of contract Illinois insurance lawyer trust payments Illinois medical malpractice attorney slip and fall accidents traumatic brain injury Palatine estate planning lawyer social media after death Illinois lawyer llinois Real Estate Lawyers Association Illinois red light cameras GM ignition switches unpaid overtime Crystal Lake law firm personal injury lawyer Des Plaines DUI attorney Illinois traffic attorneys boating under the influence agent Barrington personal injury lawyer employment contract Inverness insurance attorney preventing accidents pedestrian injuries, pedestrian fatality nursing home negligence Illinois will lawyer DUI probate claims anesthesia errors Illinois Transfer on Death Instrument Illinois wrongful termination lawyer work unions Des Plaines drug crimes lawyer Palatine drug lawyer breathalyzer test senior citizens Inverness probate lawyer Illinois home inspection Rolling Meadows business lawyer Buffalo Grove probate lawyer insurance dispute Illinois DUI attorney Schaumburg estate planning lawyer medical malpractice, missed diagnosis, delayed diagnosis, medical mistake, Deer Creek medical malpractice lawyers spinal cord injuries Illinois insurance dispute lawyers Colin Gilbert Rolling Meadows marijuana attorney federal regulations for LLCs Palatine punch death Illinois criminal defense attorney ken apicella real estate attorney Chicago insurance claim attorneys manufacturing operating agreements trauma after an accident real estate closing Family Medical Leave Act foreclosure minimum wage tax attorney Illinois employment law firm controlled substance blended families Illinois attorney product liability Palatine employment law lawyer Inverness estate planning lawyer medical malpractice Illinois insurance disputes Chicago will attorney, social media platforms, Illinois estate planning lawyer, financial advisors license dynasty trusts overtime violations Buffalo Grove corporate attorney Illinois employment laws Kenilworth estate planning attorneys Schaumburg employment attorney Chicago attorney Illinois business lawyer Arlington Heights trucking lawyer Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission Chicago estate planning Illinois personal injury Arlington Heights lawyer Illinois medical malpractice lawyers Illinois pedestrian accident attorney Attorney Ken Apicella driving BUI Barrington employment law attorney Mount Prospect real estate lawyer workers compensation benefits Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyers civil litigation Illinois real estate insurance dispute, insurance dispute lawyers, insurance claim denial, insurance claim delays, Rolling Meadows insurance dispute attorneys institutional trustee hiring employees BAIID forming a corporation in Illinois Illinois speeding lawyer living trust Rolling Meadows corporate lawyer Des Plaines collections attorney life insurance lawyer Chicago lawyer rollover accidents murder defense Illinois employment law attorneys taxes Home Remodeling Repair Act criminal defense Barrington employment attorney Barrington criminal lawyer Illinois car accident attorney texting while driving insurance negligence DUI penalities probate process Crystal Lake medical malpractice law firm denied insurance claims probate digital information personal injury, auto accident injuries, delayed injuries, serious injuries, Des Plaines personal injury attorneys Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act Schaumburg employment law attorneys Barrington employment law firm liability FSLA privacy laws condo association automated cars Deer Park traffic accident attorney Illinois workers compensation attorney whistleblower protections liens insurance claim dispute attorney liability claims Barrington medical malpractice lawyers Crystal Lake employment attorney insurance disputes, Illinois insurance disputes, Illinois insurance dispute attorneys, denied insurance claims, Arlington Heights insurance dispute attorneys landlord Mt Prospect Attorney preventable medical errors back injuries Illinois business law atorneys income distribution deducation Illinois small business Des Plaines personal injury lawyer murder Rolling Meadows Traffic Lawyer installment contracts insurance denial appeals Schaumburg corporate attorney Illinois civil litigation lawyer Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyer Rolling Meadows real estate attorney employment law unpaid assessment Illinois driving without license insurance claim dispute Rolling Meadows personal injury attorney motorcycle accident products liability medication errors Buffalo Grove law firm Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorneys Des Plaines motorcycle accident attorney Schaumburg Affordable Care Act Illinois traffic accident lawyer Arlington Heights real estate lawyer insurance agents Des Plaines civil attorney trench injuries estate planning, death tax, succession plans, business estate plans, Barrington estate planning lawyers clemency digital media accounts, estate planning, Arlington Heights estate planning attorney, Illinois workers compensation lawyer license reinstatement Buffalo Grove criminal defense lawyer workplace sexual harassment Illinois insurance claim attorney Rolling Meadows boating crash lawyer Des Plaines criminal attorney Class A misdemeanor workers compensation IRS traffic deaths Buffalo Grove insurance claim dispute lawyers murder charges unfunded trust Deer Park employment law attorney Inverness real estate lawyer LLCs low-ball insurance settlement internet Palatine traffic lawyer trucking accidents deadly crashes Illinois medical malpractice claim Mount Prospect elder law attorney gift taxes Chicago car accident lawyer problem employees Arlington Heights insurance attorney natural gas explosion suspended license accidental death benefits compensatory time Arlington Heights employment law attorneys Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers, insurance dispute Long Grove estate planning attorneys Rolling Meadows estate planning attorney rumble strips Schaumburg Attorney life insurance policy traffic laws PTSD Illinois trucking safety DUI attorney Barrington boating accident attorney Schaumburg real estate lawyer Buffalo Grove employment lawyer Crystal Lake estate planning lawyer Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyers head on collisions cell phone tower data Chicago estate planning lawyer job lawyers employee misclassification personal injury law firm insurance disputes swimming pools Buffalo Grove personal injury lawyer Rolling Meadows Attorney Thanksgiving Crystal Lake traffic lawyer Illinois estate planning expungement Barrington injury attorney condo car accident Illinois employment law attorney Palatine real estate lawyer in terrorem provision employee rights Rolling Meadows criminal lawyer brain injury blood alcohol content Crystal Lake pet attorney involuntary manslaughter guardianship attorney Schaumburg estate planning attorney commercial leasing FMLA Arlington Heights personal injury attorney Illinois wills and trusts fault based insurance DUI defense Schaumburg car accident attorney Buffalo Grove medical malpractice lawyers IRELA Deer Park personal injury lawyer car accident lawyers Joliet general practice lawyers Barrington attorney caregiver Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers no contest clauses Illinois estate planning attorney overtime pay marijuana crimes attorney Palatine trusts lawyer Des Plaines medical malpractice attorney pet bites Rolling Meadows employment law attorneys caretaker rights employee discrimination unauthorized overtime vacation home fines drug possession holiday statistics Rolling Meadows tax attorney Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorneys Crystal Lake medical malpractice lawyer special needs trust probate lawyer wrongful termination, employment law, whistleblower protections, Illinois employment laws, discrimination in the workplace cell phone accidents disability benefits contracts Illinois insurance claims lawyers Illinois employment attorneys wills BAC right to work