The Case of Bear v. Goldilocks

Web Admin - Thursday, February 27, 2014

illinois criminal civil lawyerWhile people often see the story of Goldilocks and the Three Bears as nothing more than a children’s story, it can also act as a simple overview of the legal system. After all, Goldilocks commits a variety of different offenses, both civil and criminal, throughout the story. 

The difference between a civil case and a criminal case is that a civil case involves a dispute between two private parties, the Bears and Goldilocks, while the criminal case involves the state pursuing Goldilocks for her illegal actions. Of course, many of Goldilocks’ actions can give rise to both civil liability and criminal charges.

The Civil Case: Bear v. Goldilocks

The Bears have three claims for which they may be able to sue Goldilocks: trespassing on their land, conversion of the porridge, and conversion of the chair. The Bears can easily show that Goldilocks trespassed on their land, but they will likely not receive any money for doing so, since her act of trespassing did not appear to cause any actual damage on its own. 

As for the claims of conversion, the Bears must show three things: that they owned the porridge and chair, that Goldilocks took some act inconsistent with that ownership, and that their property was damaged by Goldilocks’ acts. Since Goldilocks ate the porridge, and then sat in and broke the chair, the Bears can show that she converted those items and recover their value from Goldilocks.

The Criminal Case: The People v. Goldilocks

The state could also bring criminal charges against Goldilocks for all three of those same actions. These charges would be criminal trespass to land, petty theft of the porridge, and criminal damage to property for breaking the chair. However, the state would not have as easy a case as the Bears did suing for those same actions.

Trespassing is a crime in Illinois punishable by up to a $500 fine and six months in jail, but in order to be guilty of trespassing, a person must enter the land after being warned not to, or they must stay on the land after being told to leave. Unless the Bears had posted a sign warning trespassers, it would only be a civil offense. On the other hand, if Goldilocks had entered the house with a plan to commit a crime, she would be guilty of burglary, a class 2 felony punishable by up to 14 years in prison.

The petty theft of the porridge is an easier case. She clearly steals the porridge by eating it, and in Illinois the seriousness of the theft is determined by the value of the item. Since the porridge was probably worth less than $500, it would be petty theft, a class A misdemeanor punishable by up to a $2500 fine and one year in prison.

The state could also press charges against her for criminal damage to property for her breaking the chair, but this would likely fail. In Illinois, a person must knowingly damage the property to be guilty of the criminal offense. Because Goldilocks did not know she would break the chair if she sat in it, that charge would probably fail.

If you have recently found yourself involved with criminal charges or civil litigation, contact an attorney today. A Rolling Meadows criminal defense or civil litigation attorney can put their knowledge and legal experience to work for you. Our team serves clients across the northwest suburbs, in areas such as Schaumburg, Palatine, Barrington, and Inverness.

About the Author: Founding partner of Drost, Gilbert, Andrew & Apicella, LLC, Colin Gilbert, received his J.D. from Chicago-Kent College of law in 2005. Colin argues cases across many practice areas including criminal defense, collections, real estate law, and corporate law. He is involved in his local Illinois community as an active member of the DuPage County Bar Association, Northwest Suburban Bar Association, and the Arlington Heights Chamber of Commerce. In 2012, Colin was nominated for 2012 Business Leader of the Year by the Chamber.

Recent Posts


power of attorney for healthcare field sobriety test drugs construction accidents, personal injury, wrongful death, Arlington Heights personal injury attorneys, workers' compensation Deer Park workers compensation lawyer Inverness injury lawyer job lawyers Palatine employment attorney estate planning Des Plaines collections attorney minimum wage Illinois defective products attorney Des Plaines personal injury lawyers Barrington Traffic Lawyer tax attorney loopholes Buffalo Grove medical malpractice lawyers Illinois traffic ticket lawyer institutional trustee speeding condo insufficient documentation Illinois business law atorneys distracted driving accident victims Rolling Meadows employment attorney capital gains tax personal injury, auto accident injuries, delayed injuries, serious injuries, Des Plaines personal injury attorneys consent to a search Illinois LLC creation South Barrington real estate lawyer homestead rights Riverwoods estate planning lawyer Chicago employment lawyer disability benefits Illinois workers compensation lawyer rollover car crashes Legal Info college kids trusts contracts Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyers low-ball insurance settlement Long Grove estate planning attorneys Rolling Meadows litigation lawyer Des Plaines real estate attorney Buffalo Grove corporate attorney Inverness personal injury attorney commercial leasing Illinois estate planning law firm Forcible Entry probate process marijuana Palatine injury attorney Illinois lawyer Crystal Lake estate planning lawyer Transfer on Death Instrument small business wills auto accidents crossover accidents Barrington injury attorney Illinois bicycle safety Crystal Lake will lawyer Palatine law firm Crystal Lake car accident lawyer Super Mario overtime violations digital information sexual images premises liability Mount Prospect wills and trusts lawyers POA guardianship attorney Buffalo Grove car accident lawyer Schaumburg criminal law attorney appealing an insurance claim fiduciary rule delay Illinois Sales Representative Act Buffalo Grove traffic lawyers advance healthcare directive Palatine insurance lawyer Crystal Lake accident attorney expungement employment law Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyer Policy Cancellation Inverness elder law lawyer Chicago will attorney comparative negligence car crash injuries Chicago insurance claim attorneys Buffalo Grove insurance claim dispute lawyers Chicago traffic lawyer owner responsibility jet ski accidents Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyers underfunded trust Illinois employment law attorneys cell phone tower data head on collisions Illinois employment law attorney Illinois boating accident lawyer digital media accounts, estate planning, Arlington Heights estate planning attorney, no contest clauses Barrington employment attorney CAM Arlington Heights insurance attorney Deer Park DUI lawyer rest breaks GM ignition switches DUI Palatine estate planning lawyer Palatine workers compensation lawyer construction contracts Chicago trucking accident attorney deadly crashes car accident DGAA Buffalo Grove criminal defense lawyer nursing home negligence denied insurance claims Palatine criminal defense lawyer Crystal Lake personal injury attorney DNR life insurance policy license suspension liability claims personal injury accidents Arlington Heights TBI attorney attorney fees estate tax Joliet general practice lawyers trench injuries Illinois employee rights attorney. mortgage Illinois will lawyer IRELA Crystal Lake personal injury lawyer insurance claim insurance dispute Illinois Transfer on Death Instrument trucking accident lawyers Kenilworth estate planning attorneys estate planning, death tax, succession plans, business estate plans, Barrington estate planning lawyers IRA trust transfer Illinois employment law Chicago employment attorney living trust Deer Park medical malpractice attorney Rolling Meadows traffic attorney whistleblower protections employee misclassification Home Remodeling Repair Act Illinois workers compensation attorney real estate Chicago estate planning Fair Labor Standards Act wills and trusts Palatine employment law lawyer personal injury claims sexual harassment personal injury landlord murder Rolling Meadows DUI lawyer Illinois medical malpractice claim trucking accidents insurance claim dispute attorney pedestrian injuries, pedestrian fatality Schaumburg personal injury lawyers medical malpractice claims Illinois personal injury attorney car accident lawyer Mount Prospect real estate lawyer car collision icy parking lots rollover accidents Des Plaines workplace sexual harassment gift taxes sole proprietorship Mt Prospect Attorney Illinois criminal defense attorney Barrington estate planning attorney controlled substance Deer Park personal injury lawyer Rolling Meadows Traffic Lawyer Rolling Meadows boating crash lawyer Illinois trucking safety special needs trust real estate leasing Chicago insurance law firm texting and driving privacy Palatine Attorney Palatine probate lawyer Arlington Heights employment attorney Chicago car accident lawyer llinois Real Estate Lawyers Association Des Plaines motorcycle accident attorney Colin H. Gilbert Illinois registered agent traffic violations Illinois medical malpractice case Illinois insurance claims lawyers boating DUI pedestrian-automobile accident material misrepresentation workers compensation Palatine civil litigation lawyer Arlington Heights pedestrian accidents Palatine punch death personal injury lawyer real estate closing Class A misdemeanor Arlington Heights personal injury attorney Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers comp time Illinois employment laws Rolling Meadows employment law attorneys Crystal Lake pedestrian accident lawyer Illinois Crystal Lake employment attorney Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorneys condo association startup company Crystal Lake traffic lawyer Illinois Human Rights Act new real estate form Rolling Meadows employment law attorney Illinois personal injury lawyer insurance disputes Schaumburg personal injury lawyer Illinois insurance attorney traffic laws employment contract, employment law, employment at-will, Deer Park employment law attorneys, contract, Crystal Lake traffic attorney golf accidents Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act Illinois pedestrian accident attorney South Barrington real estate attorney foreclosure ACA unpaid assessment Illinois medical malpractice attorney hands free device anesthesia errors Chicago lawyer Chicago biking tips criminal law digital assets, digital fiduciary, estate planning, digital content, Long Grove estate planning lawyers Buffalo Grove life insurance attorney cause-of-death exclusions Illinois business lawyer loss of consortium fault based insurance insurance claim denial DUI defense Crystal lake insurance dispute attorney Arlington Heights Attorney compensatory time life insurance Crystal Lake pet attorney unauthorized overtime slip and fall insurance denials Chicago corporate attorney Landlord Tenant Ordinance Illinois rollover accident lawyers Long Grove real estate attorney Palatine corporate attorney accidental death benefits Illinois Smoke Detector Act Chicago will attorney, social media platforms, Illinois estate planning lawyer, Rolling Meadows criminal lawyer liability criminal record right to work Chicago life insurance attorney commercial real estate Palatine employment lawyer elder abuse drug crimes Illinois real estate lawyer Barrington workers compensation attorney medical malpractice, missed diagnosis, delayed diagnosis, medical mistake, Deer Creek medical malpractice lawyers overtime pay living wills Illinois medical malpractice lawyers preventing accidents DUI attorney Arlington Heights accident attorney Schaumburg employment law attorneys Rolling Meadows truck collisions Des Plaines injury law firm civil litigation attorney Schaumburg medical malpractice lawyer Employment Discrimination Law blood alcohol content motorcycle accident lawyer Illinois small business Barrington medical malpractice lawyers Illinois workplace lawyer slip and fall accidents Palatine personal injury lawyer Arlington Heights Traffic Lawyer Palatine business attorney car crash Illinois estate planning Schaumburg elder law lawyer Illinois car accident attorney estate planning lawyer spinal cord injuries Des Plaines claims law firm fatal car accidents Palatine traffic lawyer Buffalo Grove probate lawyer Inverness real estate lawyer Crystal Lake law firm BAIID Arlington Heights estate planning attorney Rolling Meadows business lawyer Des Plaines medical malpractice attorney deed transfer insurance dispute attorney blended families Barrington Illinois estate planning lawyer Barrington boating accident attorney operating agreements Exclusions Des Plaines DUI attorney life insurance claim denial, denial of life insurance claim Rolling Meadows insurance lawyer Deer Park accident attorney Palatine life insurance lawyer beneficiary complications real estate zoning suspended license workers compensation benefits Self-Directed IRA Accounts Long Grove estate planning Des Plaines personal injury attorney wrongful death Palatine corporate law attorneys BAC Schaumburg injury lawyer Thanksgiving employment law, meal breaks, rest breaks, hotel employees, Des Plaines employment law attorneys underage DUI pet law Barrington personal injury attorney ken apicella digital evidence how to avoid common denials of life insurance claims child safety Illinois workplace discrimination attorney corporate law Buffalo Grove traffic attorney Illinois mortgages bike accident insurance agents breach of contract social media after death boating accidents living trust benefits Arlington Heights real estate lawyer Rolling Meadows real estate attorney Buffalo Grove employment lawyer denied insurance claim personal injury law firm Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers, insurance dispute IRA benefits natural gas explosion Arlington Heights traffic attorney license reinstatement murder charges LLCs workers comp Schaumburg estate planning attorney Whistleblower Claims Inverness accident lawyer trust payments Palatine trusts lawyer Rolling Meadows medical malpractice lawyers Buffalo Grove injury lawyer Barrington real estate lawyer Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorneys pay when paid contract internet insurance claims Illinois red light cameras employees Illinois wills and trusts attorneys Schaumburg estate attorney Deer Park motorcycle accident lawyer Long Grove estate planning attorney Barrington life insurance lawyer probate lawyer bad faith insurance claims cell phone murder defense dynasty trusts severance agreements Palatine traffic accidents Illinois insurance lawyer insurance disputes, Illinois insurance disputes, Illinois insurance dispute attorneys, denied insurance claims, Arlington Heights insurance dispute attorneys rumble strips Rolling Meadows insurance attorney Des Plaines personal injury lawyer Kenilworth estate planning lawyer Illinois wrongful termination lawyer Palatine elder law attorney Illinois traffic laws preventable medical errors lapse in policy drunk driving estate planning trusts denial of life insurance Deer Park traffic accident attorney traumatic brain injury most common reasons for life insurance claim denials defective products lawyer drunk driving statistics pizza emoji employment law, Illinois employment laws traffic tickets Illinois personal injury Schaumburg wrongful death attorney Des Plaines accident attorney Crystal Lake bike accident lawyer swimming pools Inverness corporate attorney Crystal Lake employment law attorney changes to mortgage law Schaumburg insurance lawyers Family Medical Leave Act boating under the influence distracted driving accidents clemency TBI Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission criminal defense insurance denial appeals meal breaks Buffalo Grove personal injury attorney manufacturing Des Plaines insurance attorney health insurance dispute probate claims Deer Park criminal attorney Inverness insurance attorney Illinois injury lawyer FSLA bicycle accidents pedestrian accident pedestrian accidents Schaumburg drug defense lawyer surgical mistakes wrongful termination, employment law, whistleblower protections, Illinois employment laws, discrimination in the workplace Barrington employment law firm irrevocable trust criminal estate planning, digital assets, Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, Illinois digital assets, Illinois estate planning, spinal cord injury dram shop law automated cars Crystal Lake tax lawyer Des Plaines drug lawyer IRS Illinois insurance disputes Inverness real estate attorney defective products Colin Gilbert healthcare claims drug crimes lawyer personal injury claim Mount Prospect elder law attorney forming a corporation in Illinois Arlington Heights car crash attorneys Arlington Heights criminal lawyer Illinois civil litigation lawyer Schaumburg car accident attorney car accidents insurance agent negligence civil rights violation liens breathalyzer test Kenilworth estate planning attorney Crystal Lake insurance lawyer estate planning for college students estate attorney Long Grove real estate lawyer traffic crimes Schaumburg construction accident lawyer creditors Illinois traffic attorneys Illinois wills and trusts Rolling Meadows personal injury attorney Crystal Lake civil litigation lawyer Rolling Meadows criminal attorney Crystal Lake injury attorney denial of insurance claim home inspection lawyer hiring employees gift tax exemption, estate planning, estate planning strategies, Illinois estate planning, South Barrington estate planning attorneys Crystal Lake criminal defense attorney wage theft Do Not Resuscitate Illinois traffic attorney digital assets license revocation Schaumburg probate attorney Crystal Lake medical malpractice lawyer top life insurance claim denials Inverness estate planning lawyer medical malpractice Des Plaines drug crimes lawyer natural gas wrongful termination Schaumburg Attorney Arlington Heights trucking lawyer holiday statistics employee discrimination Barrington estate planning lawyer Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyers BUI traffic accidents Barrington civil litigation attorney business litigation Affordable Care Act Barrington employment law attorney Illinois pet lawyer Schaumburg corporate attorney insurance claim dispute real estate attorneys traffic violations defense Detainer Actions commercial leases medical research Crystal Lake employment lawyer work unions Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyer marijuana crimes attorney Arlington Heights medical malpractice lawyer traffic offenses uninsured motorist PTSD coronavirus Inverness probate lawyer Illinois employment law firm Palatine drug lawyer DUI penalities Illinois insurance claim attorney Rolling Meadows estate planning attorney drug possession trauma after an accident Palatine construction attorney Rolling Meadows marijuana attorney Illinois speeding lawyer Rolling Meadows tax attorney Deer Park real estate law firm medical marijuana eluding a police officer product liability real estate contract Illinois collections attorney Illinois employment attorneys federal crimes modern family estate planning Rolling Meadows probate lawyer foreclosed rental property bicycle dooring accidents Fourth of July Inverness DUI lawyer Des Plaines pet law attorney Illinois insurance dispute lawyers Barrington drug crime attorney Inverness civil lawyer Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorney insurance claim delay life insurance claims Illinois construction accident attorney Illinois Probate Act of 1975 Schaumburg traffic deaths Des Plaines criminal attorney dog bites cell phone accidents fiduciary rule Liquor Control Act Chicago attorney Buffalo Grove real estate attorney power of attorney Barrington personal injury lawyer employment attorney probate taxes investment property Illinois driving without license Illinois trusts attorney in terrorem provision federal regulations for LLCs Crystal Lake business law attorneys financial advisors Illinois estate planning attorney Arlington Heights tax lawyer life insurance lawyer Illinois DUI attorney Schaumburg estate planning lawyer employee rights Arlington Heights lawyer food poisoning insurance negligence pain and suffering Schaumburg civil litigation attorney agent Schaumburg traffic lawyer FMLA Illinois motorcycle accident lawyer income distribution deducation construction accidents Illinois probate lawyer texting while driving probate claims process insurance dispute, insurance dispute lawyers, insurance claim denial, insurance claim delays, Rolling Meadows insurance dispute attorneys Rolling Meadows corporate lawyer unfunded trust Chicago estate planning lawyer dealing with problem employees civil litigation driving brain injury Rolling Meadows life insurance claim denial attorney Illinois living will Deer Park employment law attorney Schaumburg real estate lawyer paid sick leave privacy laws Illinois personal injury lawyers Barrington criminal defense lawyer Arlington Heights personal injury lawyer caregiver Des Plaines real estate lawyer Buffalo Grove personal injury lawyer Arlington Heights car accident lawyer involuntary manslaughter Inverness traffic law firm insurance attorney Des Plaines tax law firm Barrington business law firm Buffalo Grove law firm products liability Home Sale Contingencies Illinois home inspection Illinois elder law attorney Schaumburg criminal attorney insurance adjusters mass shooting Illinois employment lawyer employment contract Illinois law real estate attorney vacation home Rolling Meadows drug defense attorney insurance claim denials motorcycle accident personal injury attorney elder law Rolling Meadows traffic law firm living trust vs will Palatine civil attorney Schaumburg personal injury attorney Jay Andrew senior citizens Crystal Lake medical malpractice law firm Retaliatory Discharge DMV Des Plaines civil attorney Barrington litigation attorney estate plan residential real estate ObamaCare reckless homicide hit and run accident caretaker rights Illinois traffic accident lawyer Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act traumatic brain injuries probate fees unpaid overtime Barrington attorney Arlington Heights employment law attorneys employment lawyer independent contractor license Illinois attorney drug crime car crashes Palatine real estate lawyer problem employees Illinois jet ski accident lawyer Arlington Heights injury attorney Crystal Lake car accident attorney Attorney Ken Apicella underinsured motorist Illinois corporate lawyer car accident lawyers Deer Park traffic lawyer Barrington criminal lawyer Illinois tax attorney jet ski revenge porn medical malpractice compensation pregnant women Illinois real estate Illinois Trust Code pet bites Illinois job attorney trustee School Visitation Rights Act healthcare first degree murder Rolling Meadows accident lawyer Long Grove wills and trusts attorneys medication errors vacation home fines back injuries subcontractor Food and Drug Administration's Food Safety Modernization Act Schaumburg employment attorney filing a medical malpractice claim landlord tenant law Rolling Meadows car accident lawyers Rolling Meadows Attorney installment contracts Des Plaines Traffic Lawyer real estate lawyer Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyer rent to own real estate contracts estate planning attorney Schaumburg life insurance attorney