Automated Cars, Legal Liability, and Trolley Problems

Web Admin - Tuesday, March 17, 2015

driverless car liability, Rolling Meadows car acciddent lawyerAlthough driverless cars were squarely in the realm of science fiction until recently, Google and other companies are moving towards making them a reality at a surprisingly rapid pace. As beneficial as these cars may prove to be, there are also concerns about them from a legal standpoint. One of the major issues is the question of who the law should hold responsible in the event of a traffic accident. There are also separate concerns about legal liability and ethics when driverless cars face difficult decisions, such as in the famous Trolley Problem.

General Liability Issues

One of the biggest legal issues related to driverless cars is the question of liability for accidents. With ordinary cars, liability is usually limited to one of the drivers, but that system would not work with driverless cars for obvious reasons. Many people's first instinct is to place liability on the company that makes the car. However, there are a variety of issues with that. First, it is possible that the accident with a driverless car was not the result of error by the manufacturer, but a problem with upkeep on the part of the owner. If the car's owner did not keep it properly maintained and that resulted in an accident, it would be unusual to put liability on the car's manufacturer. Beyond that, placing that much possible liability on the company could potentially cripple the development of the driverless cars.

The other competing theory is to treat driverless cars much like we treat cars now, and require people to insure them. This would remove liability from the possibly innocent owners, but it would come at the cost of increasing how expensive driverless cars are.

The Trolley Problem

A related issue is the question of how driverless cars would deal with the Trolley Problem. The Trolley Problem is an ethical dilemma in which a person is standing at a railroad switch, and they see a train coming. They know the train is going to hit five people on its current track, but the person at the switch has the option to throw the switch, sending it down a different track and only killing one person. Although it is an ethical dilemma, it may have important legal ramifications.

For instance, suppose a child darts out in front of a driverless car, and the car’s only option to avoid the child is to crash into something else, likely injuring the passengers. The car would need to make that decision, and definitely injure either the child or the passengers. The law would then need to determine whether the victim of the car's decision would have a claim against the manufacturer.

Although driverless car accidents are still a few years off, ordinary car accidents can still cause serious injuries. If you have recently been hurt in a car crash, contact an experienced Illinois personal injury attorney today. Drost, Gilbert, Andrew & Apicella, LLC serves clients in many northwest suburban towns, such as Rolling Meadows, Palatine, and Des Plaines. 

Ken ApicellaAbout the Author: Attorney Ken Apicella is a founding partner of DGAA focusing in the areas of personal injury, employment, insurance coverage disputes, and civil litigation. Ken earned his J.D. from DePaul University College of Law in 1999. He has been named a SuperLawyers Rising Star and a Forty Illinois Attorneys Under Forty to Watch. Ken has written and lectured for the Illinois Institute for Continuing Legal Education and regularly serves as a moderator at Northwest Suburban Bar Association's Continuing Legal Education seminars.

Recent Posts


DGAA landlord tenant law workers compensation benefits workers comp personal injury pizza emoji employees Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers suspended license Crystal Lake personal injury attorney Illinois car accident attorney cause-of-death exclusions boating accidents Inverness accident lawyer financial advisors Arlington Heights accident attorney underage DUI Rolling Meadows employment attorney Schaumburg criminal law attorney Chicago employment lawyer Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers, insurance dispute trench injuries FMLA insurance dispute estate planning, death tax, succession plans, business estate plans, Barrington estate planning lawyers BUI drug crimes lawyer comp time Arlington Heights car accident lawyer low-ball insurance settlement Policy Cancellation digital information Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyer Arlington Heights employment law attorneys creditors Home Remodeling Repair Act attorney fees Illinois employment attorneys Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyer food poisoning power of attorney appealing an insurance claim overtime violations Illinois insurance claim attorney employment lawyer Do Not Resuscitate criminal defense subcontractor Arlington Heights injury attorney crossover accidents Illinois registered agent Barrington Illinois estate planning lawyer medical marijuana Rolling Meadows criminal attorney Crystal Lake injury attorney swimming pools estate planning insufficient documentation Rolling Meadows employment law attorney Chicago will attorney, social media platforms, Illinois estate planning lawyer, FSLA Forcible Entry license business litigation Schaumburg estate planning lawyer Rolling Meadows insurance attorney Legal Info Schaumburg elder law lawyer Barrington criminal defense lawyer gift taxes IRS Inverness injury lawyer Crystal Lake personal injury lawyer Family Medical Leave Act Illinois probate lawyer Rolling Meadows traffic law firm problem employees Illinois insurance claims lawyers Schaumburg personal injury attorney healthcare car crashes Des Plaines pet law attorney meal breaks Long Grove real estate lawyer estate tax Crystal Lake insurance lawyer cell phone Illinois medical malpractice attorney Barrington business law firm car accident lawyers Inverness elder law lawyer Class A misdemeanor civil litigation murder defense estate planning, digital assets, Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, Illinois digital assets, Illinois estate planning, Crystal Lake law firm startup company Crystal Lake will lawyer probate Rolling Meadows traffic attorney IRA trust transfer Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyers Illinois business law atorneys texting and driving Crystal Lake bike accident lawyer Chicago biking tips Illinois living will unauthorized overtime insurance adjusters insurance denials living trust vs will hands free device eluding a police officer blended families insurance disputes living trust Schaumburg life insurance attorney Whistleblower Claims coronavirus sole proprietorship preventable medical errors Illinois traffic attorneys Crystal Lake tax lawyer condo Inverness personal injury attorney insurance agents Deer Park real estate law firm comparative negligence Illinois red light cameras IRELA no contest clauses Palatine life insurance lawyer Arlington Heights Traffic Lawyer dynasty trusts fault based insurance beneficiary complications Arlington Heights trucking lawyer Crystal Lake employment lawyer Buffalo Grove injury lawyer Crystal Lake pedestrian accident lawyer South Barrington real estate attorney Illinois employment law back injuries Barrington employment law firm Schaumburg criminal attorney home inspection lawyer cell phone accidents advance healthcare directive Arlington Heights Attorney pain and suffering traffic laws Des Plaines real estate lawyer involuntary manslaughter Illinois criminal defense attorney BAC Chicago attorney DUI penalities Schaumburg wrongful death attorney personal injury claims vacation home fines Rolling Meadows Attorney Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorneys pay when paid contract probate process Buffalo Grove personal injury attorney Illinois rollover accident lawyers texting while driving Inverness civil lawyer Illinois traffic ticket lawyer Illinois medical malpractice claim probate claims Chicago traffic lawyer Des Plaines personal injury lawyer Schaumburg real estate lawyer Illinois Transfer on Death Instrument DUI Barrington estate planning lawyer Deer Park DUI lawyer field sobriety test Des Plaines claims law firm Illinois will lawyer Illinois construction accident attorney personal injury attorney Palatine business attorney medical malpractice drunk driving statistics Arlington Heights employment attorney Illinois pet lawyer Des Plaines civil attorney Mt Prospect Attorney senior citizens insurance dispute attorney insurance claim denials Rolling Meadows business lawyer hit and run accident pedestrian injuries, pedestrian fatality rent to own real estate contracts real estate contract Attorney Ken Apicella Inverness estate planning lawyer digital media accounts, estate planning, Arlington Heights estate planning attorney, medical malpractice compensation Palatine employment law lawyer Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act Arlington Heights personal injury attorney corporate law Schaumburg Attorney pedestrian accidents real estate attorney defective products lawyer Barrington personal injury lawyer Kenilworth estate planning lawyer caretaker rights Illinois insurance dispute lawyers Arlington Heights pedestrian accidents bike accident denial of life insurance Illinois wills and trusts disability benefits underinsured motorist trauma after an accident Illinois estate planning attorney loss of consortium paid sick leave Chicago employment attorney license suspension products liability residential real estate Des Plaines insurance attorney Palatine construction attorney Schaumburg probate attorney Des Plaines DUI attorney denial of insurance claim nursing home negligence marijuana crimes attorney Buffalo Grove corporate attorney Crystal Lake pet attorney Palatine corporate attorney compensatory time federal crimes Arlington Heights estate planning attorney Inverness insurance attorney Kenilworth estate planning attorneys Barrington attorney fatal car accidents medical research Employment Discrimination Law Barrington estate planning attorney independent contractor elder abuse Schaumburg car accident attorney filing a medical malpractice claim employment contract, employment law, employment at-will, Deer Park employment law attorneys, contract, wage theft Deer Park criminal attorney workers compensation real estate zoning probate lawyer contracts dog bites Illinois LLC creation caregiver Illinois boating accident lawyer Illinois surgical mistakes mass shooting Illinois wills and trusts attorneys Palatine civil litigation lawyer Rolling Meadows drug defense attorney Deer Park employment law attorney Crystal Lake car accident lawyer Schaumburg personal injury lawyer Illinois traffic laws Deer Park workers compensation lawyer deed transfer Illinois Smoke Detector Act Illinois business lawyer civil rights violation bicycle accidents Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorneys real estate Rolling Meadows Traffic Lawyer wrongful death Mount Prospect wills and trusts lawyers employee rights Palatine elder law attorney Illinois home inspection Mount Prospect real estate lawyer Long Grove estate planning attorneys consent to a search Illinois employee rights attorney. Barrington medical malpractice lawyers Palatine injury attorney Chicago lawyer controlled substance new real estate form sexual harassment insurance claim denial changes to mortgage law vacation home spinal cord injuries installment contracts Rolling Meadows car accident lawyers Illinois pedestrian accident attorney Des Plaines injury law firm Buffalo Grove medical malpractice lawyers Rolling Meadows tax attorney pet bites uninsured motorist estate attorney Illinois employment lawyer Barrington employment attorney Illinois employment law firm Illinois Sales Representative Act wills commercial leasing underfunded trust estate plan ObamaCare Arlington Heights real estate lawyer sexual images jet ski trusts criminal rollover accidents Arlington Heights traffic attorney Illinois estate planning elder law Illinois wrongful termination lawyer Schaumburg corporate attorney reckless homicide Illinois real estate South Barrington real estate lawyer Rolling Meadows marijuana attorney car crash injuries rollover car crashes Chicago car accident lawyer college kids Illinois collections attorney employment law, meal breaks, rest breaks, hotel employees, Des Plaines employment law attorneys Exclusions Long Grove wills and trusts attorneys privacy Long Grove estate planning attorney Palatine employment lawyer Rolling Meadows real estate attorney medical malpractice, missed diagnosis, delayed diagnosis, medical mistake, Deer Creek medical malpractice lawyers life insurance policy first degree murder Illinois employment law attorneys Illinois DUI attorney Illinois traffic accident lawyer Rolling Meadows corporate lawyer Illinois injury lawyer right to work Palatine punch death Illinois civil litigation lawyer dealing with problem employees Inverness DUI lawyer Buffalo Grove criminal defense lawyer Deer Park medical malpractice attorney condo association owner responsibility BAIID Illinois speeding lawyer health insurance dispute slip and fall accidents most common reasons for life insurance claim denials overtime pay how to avoid common denials of life insurance claims Palatine Attorney Chicago will attorney Crystal Lake employment attorney Deer Park personal injury lawyer Des Plaines personal injury lawyers Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyers Des Plaines personal injury attorney work unions preventing accidents gift tax exemption, estate planning, estate planning strategies, Illinois estate planning, South Barrington estate planning attorneys traffic crimes Palatine real estate lawyer GM ignition switches Illinois workers compensation attorney Crystal Lake medical malpractice law firm foreclosed rental property Palatine probate lawyer Schaumburg personal injury lawyers Rolling Meadows Des Plaines Crystal Lake car accident attorney Buffalo Grove employment lawyer Palatine employment attorney Illinois attorney Deer Park accident attorney Schaumburg medical malpractice lawyer estate planning attorney slip and fall Arlington Heights car crash attorneys construction accidents Des Plaines drug crimes lawyer Palatine trusts lawyer Palatine criminal defense lawyer Palatine traffic accidents llinois Real Estate Lawyers Association Crystal Lake accident attorney Crystal Lake medical malpractice lawyer institutional trustee Arlington Heights personal injury lawyer boating DUI Chicago insurance claim attorneys Rolling Meadows estate planning attorney Colin Gilbert Illinois personal injury insurance denial appeals insurance claims Illinois corporate lawyer Liquor Control Act Rolling Meadows probate lawyer car accident trucking accidents insurance disputes, Illinois insurance disputes, Illinois insurance dispute attorneys, denied insurance claims, Arlington Heights insurance dispute attorneys truck collisions internet pet law Crystal Lake civil litigation lawyer Illinois personal injury attorney Jay Andrew social media after death natural gas drug possession Affordable Care Act Buffalo Grove traffic attorney manufacturing head on collisions LLCs Arlington Heights tax lawyer Food and Drug Administration's Food Safety Modernization Act traffic accidents Illinois estate planning law firm fiduciary rule delay medical malpractice claims Illinois motorcycle accident lawyer Crystal Lake employment law attorney breach of contract DMV Illinois real estate lawyer civil litigation attorney liability claims Illinois law power of attorney for healthcare drugs blood alcohol content workplace sexual harassment Rolling Meadows accident lawyer Arlington Heights lawyer Chicago estate planning lawyer trucking accident lawyers investment property Illinois insurance attorney hiring employees premises liability Fourth of July Rolling Meadows medical malpractice lawyers Schaumburg estate attorney clemency probate claims process denied insurance claim license reinstatement estate planning trusts holiday statistics Des Plaines drug lawyer healthcare claims small business Illinois workplace lawyer top life insurance claim denials special needs trust anesthesia errors Buffalo Grove traffic lawyers Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission Chicago corporate attorney Landlord Tenant Ordinance unpaid assessment personal injury lawyer minimum wage Schaumburg traffic lawyer Schaumburg injury lawyer Inverness traffic law firm Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorney Illinois personal injury lawyers homestead rights car crash Riverwoods estate planning lawyer Des Plaines medical malpractice attorney life insurance claims insurance claim dispute trust payments life insurance lawyer child safety Palatine workers compensation lawyer rumble strips life insurance Inverness corporate attorney Self-Directed IRA Accounts Buffalo Grove law firm Illinois jet ski accident lawyer Illinois mortgages traffic offenses federal regulations for LLCs traffic violations Palatine estate planning lawyer Illinois employment law attorney Illinois job attorney personal injury law firm Deer Park traffic accident attorney job lawyers Illinois medical malpractice case Buffalo Grove life insurance attorney boating under the influence Illinois trucking safety employee misclassification Detainer Actions ACA natural gas explosion Des Plaines motorcycle accident attorney Mount Prospect elder law attorney Crystal lake insurance dispute attorney landlord insurance claim dispute attorney Illinois Trust Code guardianship attorney Buffalo Grove probate lawyer real estate closing accidental death benefits personal injury claim Schaumburg employment law attorneys foreclosure Crystal Lake estate planning lawyer Barrington personal injury attorney privacy laws insurance negligence criminal law drug crime Illinois medical malpractice lawyers life insurance claim denial, denial of life insurance claim real estate attorneys Joliet general practice lawyers operating agreements in terrorem provision employment contract ken apicella Illinois defective products attorney car collision taxes Buffalo Grove real estate attorney motorcycle accident Transfer on Death Instrument Illinois small business Home Sale Contingencies Inverness probate lawyer Barrington injury attorney Schaumburg drug defense lawyer insurance claim delay Rolling Meadows life insurance claim denial attorney Schaumburg employment law Schaumburg employment attorney deadly crashes real estate leasing Long Grove real estate attorney Schaumburg estate planning attorney fiduciary rule Palatine personal injury lawyer loopholes dram shop law Des Plaines real estate attorney auto accidents employment attorney insurance dispute, insurance dispute lawyers, insurance claim denial, insurance claim delays, Rolling Meadows insurance dispute attorneys drunk driving Chicago estate planning Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act Palatine law firm breathalyzer test traumatic brain injuries car accident lawyer driving Buffalo Grove insurance claim dispute lawyers Barrington workers compensation attorney liability estate planning for college students defective products Illinois insurance disputes Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyer Arlington Heights insurance attorney Barrington life insurance lawyer Des Plaines tax law firm living trust benefits personal injury, auto accident injuries, delayed injuries, serious injuries, Des Plaines personal injury attorneys product liability Des Plaines collections attorney agent whistleblower protections Crystal Lake traffic attorney marijuana Chicago life insurance attorney Schaumburg civil litigation attorney Illinois trusts attorney Barrington drug crime attorney insurance claim CAM Buffalo Grove personal injury lawyer DUI defense Long Grove estate planning Des Plaines accident attorney car accidents motorcycle accident lawyer estate planning lawyer DUI attorney living wills digital assets, digital fiduciary, estate planning, digital content, Long Grove estate planning lawyers cell phone tower data insurance agent negligence Barrington employment law attorney School Visitation Rights Act Chicago insurance law firm construction contracts Barrington criminal lawyer Barrington real estate lawyer denied insurance claims Retaliatory Discharge traffic tickets medication errors irrevocable trust personal injury accidents TBI traffic deaths distracted driving accidents digital evidence spinal cord injury real estate lawyer IRA benefits construction accidents, personal injury, wrongful death, Arlington Heights personal injury attorneys, workers' compensation Palatine traffic lawyer Des Plaines criminal attorney wills and trusts Illinois traffic attorney Barrington boating accident attorney bicycle dooring accidents probate fees severance agreements Inverness real estate attorney Barrington civil litigation attorney traffic violations defense murder mortgage expungement license revocation murder charges brain injury Illinois employment laws unfunded trust DNR Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyers unpaid overtime Des Plaines Traffic Lawyer rest breaks insurance attorney Illinois Probate Act of 1975 drug crimes Illinois tax attorney Rolling Meadows litigation lawyer Colin H. Gilbert Illinois insurance lawyer Crystal Lake criminal defense attorney Arlington Heights medical malpractice lawyer Crystal Lake business law attorneys Schaumburg insurance lawyers Rolling Meadows DUI lawyer trustee Rolling Meadows criminal lawyer capital gains tax employment law, Illinois employment laws pedestrian-automobile accident Deer Park traffic lawyer lapse in policy distracted driving accident victims Crystal Lake traffic lawyer Rolling Meadows insurance lawyer tax attorney modern family estate planning PTSD bad faith insurance claims Fair Labor Standards Act Rolling Meadows boating crash lawyer Chicago trucking accident attorney Inverness real estate lawyer Buffalo Grove car accident lawyer liens Illinois workplace discrimination attorney Illinois elder law attorney jet ski accidents Kenilworth estate planning attorney pedestrian accident revenge porn Barrington Traffic Lawyer commercial leases criminal record Illinois Human Rights Act Arlington Heights criminal lawyer speeding material misrepresentation Palatine insurance lawyer Palatine drug lawyer pregnant women golf accidents Illinois driving without license employee discrimination forming a corporation in Illinois Rolling Meadows employment law attorneys POA Arlington Heights TBI attorney commercial real estate traumatic brain injury income distribution deducation Super Mario wrongful termination, employment law, whistleblower protections, Illinois employment laws, discrimination in the workplace automated cars Illinois workers compensation lawyer wrongful termination Palatine corporate law attorneys Schaumburg construction accident lawyer Barrington litigation attorney Rolling Meadows personal injury attorney Thanksgiving digital assets Palatine civil attorney Illinois personal injury lawyer Illinois bicycle safety Deer Park motorcycle accident lawyer Illinois lawyer icy parking lots