How Lawyers Use Digital Evidence in Court

Web Admin - Tuesday, July 15, 2014

criminal defense digital evidenceThe advent of computer technology has reshaped the way that people communicate with each other, as well as how they treat information. This has created an interesting ripple effect in courts, which now have to deal with lawyers seeking to use digital evidence in court, which includes things like incriminating emails, computer files, and Facebook posts. 

The use of this sort of evidence comes with a variety of hurdles that an attorney must clear. The attorney must prove that the evidence is authentic and untampered with, as well as show that the records are acceptable as testimony. Prosecutors in a criminal case have a higher standard to meet, needing to show that their obtaining the evidence did not violate the defendant's privacy rights.

Hurdles to Using Digital Evidence

Lawyers face three hurdles in using digital evidence: authentication, hearsay, and privacy. Authentication refers to the need to demonstrate that the digital evidence is genuine and that no one fabricated or tampered with it. This is more difficult to show with things like emails than with physical letters because people can easily edit or alter the email's text to change the substance of the message. However, many courts still set a fairly low standard of authenticity for allowing the lawyers to present evidence to the jury; they leave the final determination of genuineness to the jury itself.

The next exception to the use of digital evidence is the rule forbidding “hearsay” testimony, which digital evidence often qualifies as. Hearsay is a statement made outside of a courtroom that the lawyer is attempting to use to prove the truth of whatever the statement is about. For instance, if a defendant is on trial for murder and one witness testifies that another witness told them they had seen the defendant commit the murder, that testimony would be hearsay since the testifying witness is just reciting an out-of-court statement.

Finally, in criminal cases, the prosecution must also show that the police obtained the evidence without violating a person's 4th Amendment rights. In many cases this means that the police must have received a warrant to perform the search, but there are exceptions to this. For instance, in the civil case of Largent v. Reed, the court determined that people do not have a “reasonable expectation of privacy” in regards to the things they post to Facebook, which would mean that a warrant would not be required to look through a person's Facebook profile.

How People Can Protect Themselves

Protecting online and digital information is a difficult prospect. Often, awareness of the public nature of things like Facebook posts, internet searches, and emails can help people stay alert to the fact that such things may be available as evidence in court. This can help modify people's behavior, and make them more careful about the sort of information that they make digitally available. Beyond that, there are some programs that can encrypt private data, but these can often be decrypted throughout the discovery process.

If you are concerned about the use of digital evidence against you in a trial, contact a Barrington criminal defense attorney today. Our firm represents clients across many northwest suburban towns like Rolling Meadows, Palatine, and Schaumburg.

About the Author: Founding partner of Drost, Gilbert, Andrew & Apicella, LLC, Colin Gilbert, received his J.D. from Chicago-Kent College of law in 2005. Colin argues cases across many practice areas including criminal defense, collections, civil litigation, real estate law, and corporate law. Colin is an active member of the Board of Governors of the Northwest Suburban Bar Association and the Illinois Creditors Bar Association. He is currently Vice President of the Arlington Heights Chamber of Commerce, and is a Commissioner for the Village of Arlington Heights. Colin has a 10.0 Attorney rating on Avvo, and was named one of the 2014 “Top 40 Under 40” Trial Lawyers in Illinois by the National Trial Lawyers Association.

Recent Posts


Rolling Meadows car accident lawyers power of attorney for healthcare Illinois speeding lawyer Des Plaines criminal attorney medical malpractice employment attorney clemency whistleblower protections car accident employment contract, employment law, employment at-will, Deer Park employment law attorneys, contract, pet law spinal cord injury Palatine employment lawyer medical marijuana DMV Illinois medical malpractice case estate attorney Des Plaines drug crimes lawyer Schaumburg probate attorney eluding a police officer Retaliatory Discharge Illinois employment law insurance claim denials Schaumburg real estate lawyer Illinois collections attorney Illinois estate planning law firm Illinois car accident attorney Schaumburg criminal law attorney pedestrian injuries, pedestrian fatality texting and driving trusts Chicago corporate attorney Home Sale Contingencies Illinois employment attorneys Chicago lawyer Long Grove estate planning Rolling Meadows Palatine corporate attorney Crystal Lake accident attorney DUI attorney Colin Gilbert life insurance claim denial, denial of life insurance claim insurance claim delay insurance claim denial disability benefits Chicago car accident lawyer commercial real estate Schaumburg elder law lawyer blended families Palatine Attorney Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyer Barrington real estate lawyer Illinois employment lawyer Palatine traffic lawyer Palatine probate lawyer Illinois wrongful termination lawyer estate planning trusts reckless homicide Deer Park traffic accident attorney Illinois elder law attorney cell phone accidents Rolling Meadows insurance lawyer living trust vs will Crystal Lake pet attorney products liability Attorney Ken Apicella Rolling Meadows medical malpractice lawyers traffic offenses Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission Palatine injury attorney Illinois criminal defense attorney Mount Prospect wills and trusts lawyers Schaumburg employment attorney breach of contract boating accidents South Barrington real estate lawyer swimming pools Illinois insurance lawyer bicycle dooring accidents Schaumburg employment law attorneys no contest clauses Deer Park accident attorney holiday statistics Des Plaines collections attorney real estate contract Des Plaines tax law firm hit and run accident Rolling Meadows probate lawyer boating DUI Schaumburg drug defense lawyer Crystal Lake insurance lawyer Des Plaines DUI attorney Des Plaines real estate attorney real estate Inverness personal injury attorney Rolling Meadows estate planning attorney Barrington life insurance lawyer IRA trust transfer meal breaks distracted driving accident victims Schaumburg estate planning lawyer Illinois attorney Palatine real estate lawyer hands free device Fourth of July Chicago will attorney Illinois LLC creation Illinois traffic attorneys Illinois mortgages drunk driving statistics real estate attorneys Rolling Meadows employment law attorneys BAC Crystal Lake medical malpractice law firm icy parking lots insurance dispute attorney Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act Illinois trusts attorney Inverness DUI lawyer wrongful termination insurance dispute small business Crystal Lake employment lawyer Schaumburg construction accident lawyer drunk driving Chicago estate planning lawyer Schaumburg injury lawyer traffic deaths Inverness insurance attorney Des Plaines pet law attorney Schaumburg estate planning attorney real estate closing dynasty trusts trustee insurance adjusters denied insurance claim Des Plaines real estate lawyer Deer Park motorcycle accident lawyer dealing with problem employees Affordable Care Act Illinois employment laws Crystal Lake employment law attorney Mt Prospect Attorney Deer Park employment law attorney Schaumburg traffic lawyer IRA benefits rollover car crashes sole proprietorship fault based insurance Inverness estate planning lawyer Rolling Meadows traffic attorney golf accidents privacy insurance denial appeals Self-Directed IRA Accounts underage DUI traffic crimes filing a medical malpractice claim life insurance Crystal Lake traffic attorney Des Plaines medical malpractice attorney personal injury attorney Detainer Actions federal regulations for LLCs owner responsibility Chicago insurance claim attorneys traumatic brain injuries DUI defense traffic violations defense truck collisions Rolling Meadows criminal attorney Schaumburg personal injury lawyer DNR employment law, meal breaks, rest breaks, hotel employees, Des Plaines employment law attorneys probate fees minimum wage civil litigation attorney controlled substance Illinois pet lawyer Deer Park workers compensation lawyer sexual images breathalyzer test Des Plaines Traffic Lawyer irrevocable trust construction accidents real estate zoning car crash injuries workers compensation criminal record Palatine life insurance lawyer Palatine estate planning lawyer power of attorney Barrington personal injury lawyer pay when paid contract living trust benefits Mount Prospect elder law attorney Illinois tax attorney fiduciary rule delay Crystal Lake traffic lawyer personal injury accidents Arlington Heights employment attorney Barrington attorney installment contracts PTSD Illinois workplace discrimination attorney Rolling Meadows personal injury attorney Rolling Meadows boating crash lawyer vacation home fines Rolling Meadows DUI lawyer Des Plaines motorcycle accident attorney digital evidence Employment Discrimination Law Palatine law firm Rolling Meadows accident lawyer Buffalo Grove injury lawyer distracted driving accidents child safety drug crime Rolling Meadows corporate lawyer estate planning attorney jet ski accidents institutional trustee estate tax Barrington workers compensation attorney boating under the influence Rolling Meadows Attorney Illinois probate lawyer FMLA Crystal Lake car accident attorney FSLA Long Grove real estate lawyer Illinois employment law attorneys Palatine workers compensation lawyer Palatine employment attorney motorcycle accident lawyer denied insurance claims license reinstatement employment lawyer Arlington Heights tax lawyer Long Grove real estate attorney Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorneys Arlington Heights lawyer defective products lawyer Schaumburg IRS Deer Park personal injury lawyer brain injury Rolling Meadows Traffic Lawyer investment property Rolling Meadows life insurance claim denial attorney Fair Labor Standards Act overtime violations Palatine insurance lawyer Illinois insurance claims lawyers Illinois Sales Representative Act Des Plaines personal injury lawyers Illinois workers compensation lawyer criminal defense operating agreements Barrington Traffic Lawyer pedestrian accidents Schaumburg personal injury attorney condo job lawyers personal injury lawyer Chicago will attorney, social media platforms, Illinois estate planning lawyer, Illinois wills and trusts attorneys DGAA rent to own real estate contracts Whistleblower Claims insurance negligence Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyers Illinois rollover accident lawyers corporate law texting while driving traumatic brain injury Illinois workers compensation attorney lapse in policy Rolling Meadows traffic law firm healthcare life insurance lawyer Des Plaines drug lawyer bicycle accidents IRELA financial advisors severance agreements creditors Barrington employment attorney Palatine criminal defense lawyer denial of insurance claim employment contract criminal law vacation home insurance claim dispute Food and Drug Administration's Food Safety Modernization Act employees modern family estate planning traffic laws Barrington boating accident attorney Palatine civil attorney pain and suffering estate planning healthcare claims foreclosed rental property commercial leasing Long Grove wills and trusts attorneys insurance agent negligence Illinois Inverness real estate attorney digital media accounts, estate planning, Arlington Heights estate planning attorney, Illinois job attorney Buffalo Grove criminal defense lawyer Buffalo Grove probate lawyer caretaker rights Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act Buffalo Grove medical malpractice lawyers wrongful death drug possession revenge porn Des Plaines injury law firm premises liability estate planning, digital assets, Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, Illinois digital assets, Illinois estate planning, compensatory time digital assets life insurance claims Mount Prospect real estate lawyer drug crimes BUI probate claims process pedestrian accident home inspection lawyer murder defense mass shooting Illinois pedestrian accident attorney Crystal Lake employment attorney Barrington Illinois estate planning lawyer Chicago trucking accident attorney blood alcohol content estate planning, death tax, succession plans, business estate plans, Barrington estate planning lawyers Policy Cancellation Illinois employee rights attorney. preventable medical errors Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyers natural gas Schaumburg insurance lawyers Inverness corporate attorney health insurance dispute POA commercial leases Kenilworth estate planning lawyer Barrington criminal lawyer civil litigation ken apicella Buffalo Grove car accident lawyer Illinois estate planning dram shop law Chicago employment attorney special needs trust Barrington injury attorney Chicago biking tips business litigation Crystal Lake business law attorneys Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers employment law, Illinois employment laws Kenilworth estate planning attorneys Palatine personal injury lawyer Crystal Lake criminal defense attorney jet ski first degree murder trucking accident lawyers Super Mario Crystal Lake civil litigation lawyer cell phone fiduciary rule civil rights violation Rolling Meadows employment law attorney startup company internet Palatine punch death Illinois real estate unfunded trust rest breaks Deer Park criminal attorney Palatine drug lawyer Palatine employment law lawyer Landlord Tenant Ordinance insurance claim dispute attorney problem employees Des Plaines personal injury attorney Buffalo Grove personal injury lawyer Illinois insurance disputes Illinois insurance claim attorney Illinois Human Rights Act top life insurance claim denials Buffalo Grove life insurance attorney comp time llinois Real Estate Lawyers Association most common reasons for life insurance claim denials Arlington Heights personal injury lawyer Chicago estate planning Kenilworth estate planning attorney cause-of-death exclusions appealing an insurance claim social media after death Buffalo Grove personal injury attorney Schaumburg Attorney uninsured motorist Arlington Heights real estate lawyer Illinois red light cameras car accidents landlord Barrington employment law firm Barrington litigation attorney medication errors federal crimes Illinois real estate lawyer income distribution deducation Arlington Heights insurance attorney motorcycle accident license Illinois civil litigation lawyer Illinois wills and trusts cell phone tower data insurance disputes, Illinois insurance disputes, Illinois insurance dispute attorneys, denied insurance claims, Arlington Heights insurance dispute attorneys sexual harassment real estate attorney Chicago life insurance attorney forming a corporation in Illinois Des Plaines insurance attorney Illinois estate planning attorney work unions Illinois Trust Code beneficiary complications traffic violations Forcible Entry homestead rights unpaid assessment elder law medical research unauthorized overtime gift tax exemption, estate planning, estate planning strategies, Illinois estate planning, South Barrington estate planning attorneys Rolling Meadows employment attorney living wills murder charges Illinois corporate lawyer insurance dispute, insurance dispute lawyers, insurance claim denial, insurance claim delays, Rolling Meadows insurance dispute attorneys insurance disputes Illinois personal injury fatal car accidents Illinois defective products attorney car accident lawyers medical malpractice compensation defective products personal injury claim underinsured motorist workers compensation benefits advance healthcare directive loss of consortium Illinois home inspection Illinois medical malpractice attorney Illinois trucking safety Arlington Heights estate planning attorney Inverness elder law lawyer ACA Inverness civil lawyer Illinois traffic laws Buffalo Grove real estate attorney Long Grove estate planning attorney Illinois business lawyer slip and fall Illinois traffic ticket lawyer Arlington Heights medical malpractice lawyer Illinois personal injury attorney Crystal Lake car accident lawyer Inverness accident lawyer criminal Chicago attorney suspended license living trust traffic tickets BAIID elder abuse employee rights Illinois insurance dispute lawyers senior citizens Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorney Illinois driving without license liability claims probate process landlord tenant law Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers, insurance dispute unpaid overtime estate planning lawyer Arlington Heights accident attorney Crystal Lake will lawyer agent comparative negligence Crystal Lake personal injury lawyer Illinois living will Chicago employment lawyer manufacturing subcontractor car crash right to work Arlington Heights traffic attorney surgical mistakes Arlington Heights car crash attorneys DUI penalities medical malpractice claims insurance agents Palatine business attorney Joliet general practice lawyers Arlington Heights Attorney Inverness traffic law firm Inverness injury lawyer Barrington criminal defense lawyer Crystal Lake personal injury attorney Des Plaines personal injury lawyer marijuana Thanksgiving Deer Park real estate law firm Chicago traffic lawyer Schaumburg criminal attorney consent to a search trauma after an accident Family Medical Leave Act coronavirus employee discrimination license suspension product liability Illinois bicycle safety Illinois traffic attorney deadly crashes Rolling Meadows tax attorney foreclosure Inverness real estate lawyer Illinois business law atorneys Buffalo Grove insurance claim dispute lawyers Illinois employment law attorney hiring employees contracts drugs estate planning for college students Des Plaines paid sick leave Long Grove estate planning attorneys Buffalo Grove corporate attorney driving Barrington drug crime attorney Do Not Resuscitate Rolling Meadows insurance attorney Schaumburg wrongful death attorney Barrington civil litigation attorney Home Remodeling Repair Act Illinois Smoke Detector Act Arlington Heights Traffic Lawyer Schaumburg personal injury lawyers mortgage personal injury law firm trench injuries Schaumburg corporate attorney how to avoid common denials of life insurance claims guardianship attorney rollover accidents Barrington medical malpractice lawyers construction contracts Illinois employment law firm Illinois lawyer TBI preventing accidents Arlington Heights car accident lawyer Crystal Lake law firm Barrington estate planning lawyer deed transfer Buffalo Grove employment lawyer Jay Andrew wills Palatine traffic accidents underfunded trust dog bites pizza emoji loopholes CAM Deer Park DUI lawyer Des Plaines civil attorney Rolling Meadows business lawyer Illinois DUI attorney life insurance policy Deer Park traffic lawyer Buffalo Grove law firm Illinois motorcycle accident lawyer head on collisions Transfer on Death Instrument Buffalo Grove traffic lawyers pregnant women changes to mortgage law Rolling Meadows litigation lawyer Illinois boating accident lawyer Illinois traffic accident lawyer Arlington Heights pedestrian accidents gift taxes slip and fall accidents Illinois injury lawyer Rolling Meadows marijuana attorney Illinois small business bad faith insurance claims Crystal Lake bike accident lawyer taxes privacy laws employee misclassification wills and trusts in terrorem provision murder Legal Info new real estate form South Barrington real estate attorney wage theft Schaumburg life insurance attorney insurance claims independent contractor Des Plaines accident attorney personal injury, auto accident injuries, delayed injuries, serious injuries, Des Plaines personal injury attorneys Crystal Lake pedestrian accident lawyer Illinois insurance attorney involuntary manslaughter car collision wrongful termination, employment law, whistleblower protections, Illinois employment laws, discrimination in the workplace Deer Park medical malpractice attorney low-ball insurance settlement Buffalo Grove traffic attorney residential real estate Barrington estate planning attorney Illinois personal injury lawyers Schaumburg estate attorney natural gas explosion food poisoning condo association pet bites Liquor Control Act Arlington Heights criminal lawyer rumble strips Arlington Heights personal injury attorney accidental death benefits Rolling Meadows real estate attorney estate plan Colin H. Gilbert Arlington Heights employment law attorneys Rolling Meadows drug defense attorney probate claims Illinois registered agent back injuries insurance attorney Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyers auto accidents Arlington Heights trucking lawyer Palatine elder law attorney Crystal Lake injury attorney pedestrian-automobile accident license revocation crossover accidents Illinois Transfer on Death Instrument liability denial of life insurance Illinois workplace lawyer anesthesia errors overtime pay Crystal lake insurance dispute attorney probate traffic accidents construction accidents, personal injury, wrongful death, Arlington Heights personal injury attorneys, workers' compensation personal injury GM ignition switches Barrington employment law attorney Palatine civil litigation lawyer car crashes digital assets, digital fiduciary, estate planning, digital content, Long Grove estate planning lawyers insufficient documentation workplace sexual harassment Crystal Lake estate planning lawyer tax attorney trucking accidents Crystal Lake medical malpractice lawyer Barrington personal injury attorney personal injury claims LLCs Inverness probate lawyer drug crimes lawyer workers comp DUI car accident lawyer Palatine trusts lawyer trust payments Illinois law Illinois medical malpractice claim Class A misdemeanor Illinois will lawyer real estate lawyer digital information material misrepresentation spinal cord injuries field sobriety test Exclusions real estate leasing bike accident automated cars expungement Riverwoods estate planning lawyer Palatine construction attorney Illinois personal injury lawyer capital gains tax Des Plaines claims law firm attorney fees speeding Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyer insurance claim School Visitation Rights Act Crystal Lake tax lawyer Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorneys Chicago insurance law firm employment law medical malpractice, missed diagnosis, delayed diagnosis, medical mistake, Deer Creek medical malpractice lawyers nursing home negligence Palatine corporate law attorneys ObamaCare Illinois construction accident attorney Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyer Schaumburg car accident attorney liens caregiver Arlington Heights TBI attorney Illinois Probate Act of 1975 Illinois medical malpractice lawyers Illinois jet ski accident lawyer Schaumburg civil litigation attorney Barrington business law firm probate lawyer marijuana crimes attorney Arlington Heights injury attorney Rolling Meadows criminal lawyer insurance denials Schaumburg medical malpractice lawyer college kids