Study Finds Most Doctors Are Confused by Living Wills

Web Admin - Friday, February 24, 2017

Barrington medical malpractice lawyersLiving wills are, quite literally, a matter of life and death. They are also fairly common documents, which means doctors and surgeons should know how to interpret them. Yet a recent study has determined that, much of the time, they interpret these documents incorrectly. Besides having the wishes expressed in their living will violated, what might this mean for patients and their families? The following explains. 

A Closer Look at the Study

Published in the Journal of Patient Safety, the recent study asked 741 physicians from 13 different hospitals to detail how they would treat nine different patients with varying degrees of cardiopulmonary distress, based on what they understood from the patients’ living wills. They only reached a consensus (defined as agreement of 95 percent or higher) in two out of the nine scenarios. If they viewed a one-minute video that expressed each patient’s wishes, along with reading the living will, they reached a 94 percent agreement on a third patient. 

What was most disturbing about this is that, out of those remaining cases, many doctors got the answer wrong. Some would have given too much treatment to a patient who did not want specific life-saving procedures and practices. Others would have given too little treatment, potentially placing the patient at risk for death when they wanted life-saving practices and procedures. The implications of either are concerning, to say the least. 

What Happens When Doctors Misinterpret Living Wills

Patients who have a do-not-resuscitate (DNR) in place typically have one for a particular reason. Perhaps they simply do not want to risk the chances of being left in a vegetative state, or making their families decide when to pull the plug. Others may have chronic and debilitating conditions that are eroding their health. 

In contrast, patients who want certain life-saving procedures and practices have reasons for wanting to live. Maybe they have children, or are simply okay with certain practices but not others. They can express these specific wishes through their living will. Yet, if they are not interpreted correctly, patients and their families may experience a wrongful death, or a situation where they are revived and forced to live in a way they might not wanted (i.e. being in a comatose state or on life support). Both situations could pave the way for a medical malpractice lawsuit. 

Contact Our Barrington Medical Malpractice Lawyers

If you or someone you love has experienced wrongful death or improper treatment, despite having a living will in place, the experienced Barrington medical malpractice attorneys at Drost, Gilbert, Andrew & Apicella, LLC can help. Dedicated and experienced, we will fight for the most compensation possible in your case. Learn more by calling 847-934-6000 today.

Ken ApicellaAbout the Author: Attorney Ken Apicella is a founding partner of DGAA focusing in the areas of personal injury, employment, insurance coverage disputes, and civil litigation. Ken earned his J.D. from DePaul University College of Law in 1999. He has been named a SuperLawyers Rising Star and a Forty Illinois Attorneys Under Forty to Watch. Ken has written and lectured for the Illinois Institute for Continuing Legal Education and regularly serves as a moderator at Northwest Suburban Bar Association's Continuing Legal Education seminars.


Recent Posts


Illinois wills and trusts Schaumburg personal injury attorney Rolling Meadows Des Plaines personal injury lawyers Illinois trusts attorney underfunded trust Liquor Control Act probate employee misclassification Illinois trucking safety Des Plaines Traffic Lawyer insurance disputes Crystal Lake business law attorneys DMV Barrington personal injury attorney South Barrington real estate lawyer uninsured motorist DGAA insurance claim dispute attorney income distribution deducation insurance claim jet ski living trust vs will civil rights violation holiday statistics Barrington criminal lawyer Arlington Heights Traffic Lawyer liens Schaumburg medical malpractice lawyer Class A misdemeanor Illinois LLC creation Illinois pet lawyer estate planning, digital assets, Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, Illinois digital assets, Illinois estate planning, Illinois personal injury real estate lawyer internet Arlington Heights accident attorney Illinois civil litigation lawyer Crystal Lake bike accident lawyer employment contract, employment law, employment at-will, Deer Park employment law attorneys, contract, trucking accident lawyers DNR commercial leasing Crystal Lake insurance lawyer pedestrian accidents wills and trusts Home Sale Contingencies Inverness civil lawyer Chicago will attorney Schaumburg drug defense lawyer eluding a police officer Detainer Actions car crashes car accident lawyer motorcycle accident lawyer Rolling Meadows corporate lawyer Chicago lawyer Barrington workers compensation attorney criminal Illinois car accident attorney civil litigation attorney Crystal Lake pedestrian accident lawyer Illinois medical malpractice lawyers Attorney Ken Apicella Buffalo Grove probate lawyer Des Plaines collections attorney Illinois insurance lawyer Palatine trusts lawyer Crystal Lake personal injury lawyer texting and driving no contest clauses Arlington Heights Attorney employment law, meal breaks, rest breaks, hotel employees, Des Plaines employment law attorneys DUI defense Long Grove real estate attorney premises liability Barrington litigation attorney surgical mistakes drugs Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorneys taxes Rolling Meadows Traffic Lawyer insurance dispute murder defense boating accidents Illinois Sales Representative Act bike accident expungement Inverness injury lawyer product liability nursing home negligence Rolling Meadows estate planning attorney Illinois job attorney insurance disputes, Illinois insurance disputes, Illinois insurance dispute attorneys, denied insurance claims, Arlington Heights insurance dispute attorneys Des Plaines real estate attorney Arlington Heights injury attorney personal injury law firm Illinois motorcycle accident lawyer Illinois Transfer on Death Instrument Barrington business law firm Whistleblower Claims Chicago corporate attorney Schaumburg traffic lawyer insurance agent negligence estate plan car crash Des Plaines medical malpractice attorney Long Grove estate planning attorney Des Plaines Crystal Lake personal injury attorney insurance negligence swimming pools Arlington Heights employment law attorneys Buffalo Grove insurance claim dispute lawyers healthcare claims slip and fall bicycle dooring accidents Joliet general practice lawyers Rolling Meadows personal injury attorney Illinois workers compensation attorney privacy Deer Park DUI lawyer Self-Directed IRA Accounts real estate closing Illinois rollover accident lawyers pet law Mt Prospect Attorney insurance dispute attorney Palatine civil attorney Illinois medical malpractice case Illinois personal injury lawyer medication errors Barrington medical malpractice lawyers Illinois traffic attorneys Illinois defective products attorney underage DUI BUI Illinois lawyer Thanksgiving fault based insurance Buffalo Grove medical malpractice lawyers Illinois workplace lawyer senior citizens Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyer Mount Prospect wills and trusts lawyers Employment Discrimination Law creditors vacation home wrongful termination, employment law, whistleblower protections, Illinois employment laws, discrimination in the workplace Barrington attorney Illinois workplace discrimination attorney startup company Deer Park medical malpractice attorney real estate attorneys consent to a search ObamaCare Rolling Meadows probate lawyer boating DUI drug possession real estate attorney llinois Real Estate Lawyers Association deed transfer traffic crimes murder charges GM ignition switches Schaumburg Attorney real estate zoning capital gains tax TBI Schaumburg civil litigation attorney drunk driving statistics Illinois Smoke Detector Act caretaker rights Buffalo Grove personal injury lawyer Rolling Meadows business lawyer pain and suffering probate claims process pet bites Barrington estate planning attorney living trust estate planning trusts Illinois small business drug crimes lawyer installment contracts Schaumburg construction accident lawyer minimum wage underinsured motorist real estate leasing traffic violations probate process Illinois business law atorneys Riverwoods estate planning lawyer IRELA jet ski accidents spinal cord injury Buffalo Grove traffic lawyers Palatine drug lawyer distracted driving accident victims Buffalo Grove employment lawyer pizza emoji Food and Drug Administration's Food Safety Modernization Act Illinois attorney Schaumburg employment attorney Illinois corporate lawyer Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyers traffic laws wills Barrington real estate lawyer employment law car collision Chicago employment attorney Chicago traffic lawyer liability claims Palatine estate planning lawyer Arlington Heights personal injury attorney drunk driving Illinois collections attorney denied insurance claim Crystal Lake estate planning lawyer Barrington Traffic Lawyer Schaumburg wrongful death attorney Long Grove estate planning Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorney severance agreements Illinois Probate Act of 1975 Buffalo Grove corporate attorney car accident Palatine traffic lawyer Des Plaines insurance attorney Palatine corporate attorney privacy laws Des Plaines claims law firm Schaumburg estate planning lawyer Chicago will attorney, social media platforms, Illinois estate planning lawyer, Arlington Heights trucking lawyer POA disability benefits Illinois elder law attorney revenge porn Illinois law Illinois Deer Park criminal attorney suspended license Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers, insurance dispute insurance claims BAC Chicago insurance claim attorneys institutional trustee Super Mario Do Not Resuscitate Illinois employment laws Crystal Lake will lawyer Chicago estate planning lawyer real estate contract college kids IRS natural gas explosion Arlington Heights tax lawyer Palatine elder law attorney personal injury claim Illinois medical malpractice claim sexual harassment Arlington Heights personal injury lawyer Legal Info traumatic brain injuries job lawyers IRA benefits federal regulations for LLCs trustee insurance attorney involuntary manslaughter Landlord Tenant Ordinance subcontractor loss of consortium Affordable Care Act Arlington Heights lawyer Crystal Lake medical malpractice law firm DUI penalities defective products lawyer Long Grove estate planning attorneys ACA spinal cord injuries independent contractor criminal defense workplace sexual harassment Family Medical Leave Act Illinois employment lawyer Des Plaines injury law firm Long Grove wills and trusts attorneys employee discrimination Illinois real estate lawyer Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act Des Plaines pet law attorney federal crimes estate attorney Inverness elder law lawyer overtime pay landlord special needs trust Illinois home inspection Illinois insurance claim attorney personal injury claims Rolling Meadows boating crash lawyer power of attorney for healthcare Schaumburg corporate attorney Palatine criminal defense lawyer dealing with problem employees Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers attorney fees comparative negligence Chicago employment lawyer Barrington employment law firm Crystal Lake criminal defense attorney Schaumburg car accident attorney Des Plaines drug lawyer Inverness accident lawyer Deer Park motorcycle accident lawyer Palatine real estate lawyer work unions Palatine traffic accidents pedestrian injuries, pedestrian fatality rollover car crashes Crystal Lake employment attorney CAM breathalyzer test Illinois boating accident lawyer field sobriety test Illinois will lawyer Illinois traffic ticket lawyer Crystal Lake tax lawyer Illinois insurance disputes probate lawyer social media after death wrongful termination whistleblower protections advance healthcare directive small business employment attorney Schaumburg criminal law attorney pregnant women Illinois jet ski accident lawyer estate planning for college students Illinois construction accident attorney back injuries car crash injuries financial advisors Illinois real estate car accidents Palatine Attorney license suspension Schaumburg personal injury accidents Des Plaines tax law firm motorcycle accident automated cars medical malpractice, missed diagnosis, delayed diagnosis, medical mistake, Deer Creek medical malpractice lawyers changes to mortgage law residential real estate Illinois speeding lawyer operating agreements Arlington Heights pedestrian accidents Rolling Meadows insurance attorney wage theft insurance claim denial Des Plaines personal injury attorney Crystal Lake traffic attorney hands free device trusts Rolling Meadows traffic law firm reckless homicide DUI Illinois employee rights attorney. civil litigation ken apicella slip and fall accidents new real estate form preventing accidents meal breaks Inverness probate lawyer Exclusions Arlington Heights employment attorney Illinois tax attorney Illinois estate planning attorney insurance claim delay Buffalo Grove car accident lawyer drug crimes Rolling Meadows DUI lawyer appealing an insurance claim marijuana home inspection lawyer mortgage estate tax Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyers Deer Park employment law attorney Illinois traffic accident lawyer Illinois driving without license insurance claim dispute Barrington personal injury lawyer Rolling Meadows employment law attorneys crossover accidents Palatine civil litigation lawyer personal injury, auto accident injuries, delayed injuries, serious injuries, Des Plaines personal injury attorneys Rolling Meadows drug defense attorney paid sick leave probate fees Crystal Lake car accident attorney Illinois personal injury lawyers Inverness corporate attorney murder coronavirus gift taxes Illinois wrongful termination lawyer bad faith insurance claims Illinois employment attorneys modern family estate planning construction accidents landlord tenant law Kenilworth estate planning attorney BAIID license Crystal Lake traffic lawyer Rolling Meadows criminal attorney Forcible Entry Crystal Lake employment lawyer cell phone accidents traumatic brain injury Illinois insurance claims lawyers Deer Park accident attorney agent estate planning attorney business litigation foreclosure Rolling Meadows real estate attorney manufacturing Illinois criminal defense attorney Des Plaines motorcycle accident attorney Arlington Heights car accident lawyer Rolling Meadows employment attorney Rolling Meadows accident lawyer unpaid overtime traffic tickets employees Des Plaines real estate lawyer Palatine punch death preventable medical errors rumble strips Chicago insurance law firm trucking accidents compensatory time Illinois traffic laws Palatine injury attorney trauma after an accident medical malpractice compensation brain injury real estate dram shop law life insurance lawyer Inverness real estate lawyer Deer Park real estate law firm Schaumburg injury lawyer elder abuse trust payments contracts overtime violations Deer Park traffic accident attorney Crystal Lake accident attorney cell phone tower data caregiver unauthorized overtime Buffalo Grove criminal defense lawyer Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyer Rolling Meadows tax attorney commercial leases Barrington drug crime attorney pay when paid contract Deer Park personal injury lawyer boating under the influence Illinois DUI attorney Rolling Meadows marijuana attorney Des Plaines accident attorney personal injury attorney Colin Gilbert healthcare Buffalo Grove traffic attorney Retaliatory Discharge workers compensation Fourth of July deadly crashes Rolling Meadows Attorney homestead rights digital assets Buffalo Grove personal injury attorney Inverness personal injury attorney employment lawyer Inverness real estate attorney truck collisions employment law, Illinois employment laws Buffalo Grove real estate attorney defective products Illinois wills and trusts attorneys Rolling Meadows car accident lawyers Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorneys Palatine personal injury lawyer pedestrian accident Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyers Buffalo Grove law firm Palatine employment law lawyer Chicago trucking accident attorney Palatine corporate law attorneys Jay Andrew right to work personal injury corporate law Illinois injury lawyer speeding unpaid assessment traffic violations defense driving clemency DUI attorney blended families Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission Palatine business attorney Crystal Lake car accident lawyer Illinois workers compensation lawyer Arlington Heights estate planning attorney Mount Prospect elder law attorney rent to own real estate contracts Illinois employment law firm IRA trust transfer Crystal Lake injury attorney investment property Illinois employment law attorneys Palatine construction attorney natural gas Illinois probate lawyer Buffalo Grove injury lawyer probate claims Illinois Trust Code Illinois red light cameras Arlington Heights criminal lawyer Palatine insurance lawyer criminal record comp time School Visitation Rights Act Schaumburg personal injury lawyers Des Plaines personal injury lawyer fiduciary rule digital media accounts, estate planning, Arlington Heights estate planning attorney, estate planning medical malpractice claims Illinois employment law digital evidence Chicago biking tips Des Plaines DUI attorney Mount Prospect real estate lawyer breach of contract loopholes Palatine probate lawyer Illinois business lawyer life insurance claims Illinois medical malpractice attorney Deer Park workers compensation lawyer insurance adjusters Fair Labor Standards Act problem employees liability Barrington employment law attorney Palatine law firm LLCs Illinois registered agent foreclosed rental property Arlington Heights traffic attorney Long Grove real estate lawyer unfunded trust employment contract employee rights child safety Rolling Meadows traffic attorney accidental death benefits Inverness traffic law firm Barrington estate planning lawyer Barrington boating accident attorney Illinois insurance dispute lawyers traffic offenses Rolling Meadows insurance lawyer Barrington employment attorney license reinstatement fatal car accidents owner responsibility hit and run accident low-ball insurance settlement Barrington civil litigation attorney Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act Des Plaines criminal attorney sexual images fiduciary rule delay health insurance dispute personal injury lawyer dynasty trusts auto accidents Barrington injury attorney living wills Chicago estate planning Illinois employment law attorney Crystal Lake pet attorney Policy Cancellation Illinois insurance attorney irrevocable trust Rolling Meadows litigation lawyer workers compensation benefits in terrorem provision license revocation Barrington Illinois estate planning lawyer Barrington criminal defense lawyer PTSD trench injuries gift tax exemption, estate planning, estate planning strategies, Illinois estate planning, South Barrington estate planning attorneys denial of life insurance medical research bicycle accidents estate planning lawyer Illinois pedestrian accident attorney distracted driving accidents elder law Colin H. Gilbert Inverness estate planning lawyer forming a corporation in Illinois Crystal Lake employment law attorney Schaumburg employment law attorneys Transfer on Death Instrument Rolling Meadows employment law attorney insurance denials Rolling Meadows criminal lawyer traffic deaths condo association controlled substance Illinois estate planning law firm Schaumburg criminal attorney Schaumburg estate attorney Palatine employment attorney guardianship attorney blood alcohol content wrongful death Deer Park traffic lawyer Illinois personal injury attorney Schaumburg personal injury lawyer South Barrington real estate attorney Arlington Heights TBI attorney Rolling Meadows medical malpractice lawyers insurance claim denials construction accidents, personal injury, wrongful death, Arlington Heights personal injury attorneys, workers' compensation FSLA first degree murder hiring employees Arlington Heights insurance attorney rollover accidents Crystal Lake civil litigation lawyer golf accidents Illinois traffic attorney cell phone insurance dispute, insurance dispute lawyers, insurance claim denial, insurance claim delays, Rolling Meadows insurance dispute attorneys Chicago car accident lawyer Illinois bicycle safety Des Plaines drug crimes lawyer icy parking lots pedestrian-automobile accident mass shooting Illinois estate planning Schaumburg estate planning attorney Inverness DUI lawyer insurance denial appeals Schaumburg elder law lawyer texting while driving FMLA Palatine employment lawyer head on collisions estate planning, death tax, succession plans, business estate plans, Barrington estate planning lawyers life insurance policy Crystal lake insurance dispute attorney vacation home fines living trust benefits Schaumburg insurance lawyers Schaumburg real estate lawyer denied insurance claims products liability Illinois Human Rights Act Des Plaines civil attorney Palatine workers compensation lawyer marijuana crimes attorney workers comp Arlington Heights car crash attorneys Crystal Lake medical malpractice lawyer criminal law sole proprietorship Illinois mortgages medical malpractice Kenilworth estate planning attorneys traffic accidents Illinois living will Arlington Heights real estate lawyer drug crime construction contracts digital information Chicago attorney Crystal Lake law firm medical marijuana tax attorney digital assets, digital fiduciary, estate planning, digital content, Long Grove estate planning lawyers insurance agents power of attorney food poisoning life insurance dog bites Home Remodeling Repair Act commercial real estate Kenilworth estate planning lawyer car accident lawyers Inverness insurance attorney Arlington Heights medical malpractice lawyer filing a medical malpractice claim rest breaks condo Schaumburg probate attorney Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyer anesthesia errors