Study Finds Most Doctors Are Confused by Living Wills

Web Admin - Friday, February 24, 2017

Barrington medical malpractice lawyersLiving wills are, quite literally, a matter of life and death. They are also fairly common documents, which means doctors and surgeons should know how to interpret them. Yet a recent study has determined that, much of the time, they interpret these documents incorrectly. Besides having the wishes expressed in their living will violated, what might this mean for patients and their families? The following explains. 

A Closer Look at the Study

Published in the Journal of Patient Safety, the recent study asked 741 physicians from 13 different hospitals to detail how they would treat nine different patients with varying degrees of cardiopulmonary distress, based on what they understood from the patients’ living wills. They only reached a consensus (defined as agreement of 95 percent or higher) in two out of the nine scenarios. If they viewed a one-minute video that expressed each patient’s wishes, along with reading the living will, they reached a 94 percent agreement on a third patient. 

What was most disturbing about this is that, out of those remaining cases, many doctors got the answer wrong. Some would have given too much treatment to a patient who did not want specific life-saving procedures and practices. Others would have given too little treatment, potentially placing the patient at risk for death when they wanted life-saving practices and procedures. The implications of either are concerning, to say the least. 

What Happens When Doctors Misinterpret Living Wills

Patients who have a do-not-resuscitate (DNR) in place typically have one for a particular reason. Perhaps they simply do not want to risk the chances of being left in a vegetative state, or making their families decide when to pull the plug. Others may have chronic and debilitating conditions that are eroding their health. 

In contrast, patients who want certain life-saving procedures and practices have reasons for wanting to live. Maybe they have children, or are simply okay with certain practices but not others. They can express these specific wishes through their living will. Yet, if they are not interpreted correctly, patients and their families may experience a wrongful death, or a situation where they are revived and forced to live in a way they might not wanted (i.e. being in a comatose state or on life support). Both situations could pave the way for a medical malpractice lawsuit. 

Contact Our Barrington Medical Malpractice Lawyers

If you or someone you love has experienced wrongful death or improper treatment, despite having a living will in place, the experienced Barrington medical malpractice attorneys at Drost, Gilbert, Andrew & Apicella, LLC can help. Dedicated and experienced, we will fight for the most compensation possible in your case. Learn more by calling 847-934-6000 today.

Ken ApicellaAbout the Author: Attorney Ken Apicella is a founding partner of DGAA focusing in the areas of personal injury, employment, insurance coverage disputes, and civil litigation. Ken earned his J.D. from DePaul University College of Law in 1999. He has been named a SuperLawyers Rising Star and a Forty Illinois Attorneys Under Forty to Watch. Ken has written and lectured for the Illinois Institute for Continuing Legal Education and regularly serves as a moderator at Northwest Suburban Bar Association's Continuing Legal Education seminars.


Recent Posts


Inverness real estate lawyer Arlington Heights traffic attorney dram shop law defective products loss of consortium Forcible Entry Long Grove real estate attorney Buffalo Grove employment lawyer Arlington Heights criminal lawyer Chicago employment attorney Barrington injury attorney Crystal Lake injury attorney personal injury lawyer Des Plaines medical malpractice attorney elder abuse Crystal Lake business law attorneys Palatine estate planning lawyer drug possession estate planning, death tax, succession plans, business estate plans, Barrington estate planning lawyers food poisoning holiday statistics Home Remodeling Repair Act Transfer on Death Instrument probate claims process unauthorized overtime Crystal Lake will lawyer Illinois rollover accident lawyers Rolling Meadows medical malpractice lawyers employee rights child safety subcontractor accidental death benefits unpaid overtime personal injury accidents probate process Illinois mortgages Arlington Heights employment attorney traumatic brain injuries Schaumburg drug defense lawyer car accidents Barrington personal injury attorney drug crimes Arlington Heights medical malpractice lawyer Illinois motorcycle accident lawyer Crystal Lake pet attorney Illinois trucking safety products liability traffic offenses Chicago employment lawyer Illinois wills and trusts attorneys minimum wage Whistleblower Claims Illinois insurance claim attorney PTSD Deer Park real estate law firm car crash criminal Schaumburg construction accident lawyer Kenilworth estate planning lawyer South Barrington real estate lawyer Landlord Tenant Ordinance fault based insurance Chicago estate planning lawyer Barrington criminal lawyer Inverness injury lawyer Arlington Heights Attorney Mount Prospect elder law attorney Kenilworth estate planning attorneys IRELA llinois Real Estate Lawyers Association auto accidents IRA trust transfer living trust consent to a search CAM Buffalo Grove personal injury attorney Illinois home inspection employee misclassification BUI Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers Buffalo Grove criminal defense lawyer condo Illinois real estate lawyer Barrington litigation attorney low-ball insurance settlement business litigation Barrington business law firm construction accidents first degree murder capital gains tax Schaumburg elder law lawyer Des Plaines drug crimes lawyer Illinois medical malpractice attorney murder rollover car crashes Buffalo Grove real estate attorney meal breaks suspended license back injuries medical marijuana Crystal Lake pedestrian accident lawyer Rolling Meadows tax attorney manufacturing Rolling Meadows boating crash lawyer liability tax attorney motorcycle accident jet ski accidents comp time breach of contract estate attorney operating agreements Arlington Heights car accident lawyer Illinois law digital evidence Deer Park motorcycle accident lawyer Des Plaines personal injury lawyers Kenilworth estate planning attorney Illinois medical malpractice claim compensatory time Illinois insurance attorney Des Plaines pet law attorney social media after death Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorneys federal regulations for LLCs Inverness estate planning lawyer unpaid assessment Inverness insurance attorney Rolling Meadows employment attorney life insurance lawyer Crystal Lake traffic attorney Arlington Heights estate planning attorney Arlington Heights accident attorney Illinois construction accident attorney Schaumburg injury lawyer homestead rights Illinois boating accident lawyer Inverness accident lawyer pet bites license cell phone tower data Illinois Probate Act of 1975 real estate lawyer civil litigation attorney boating accidents wrongful death GM ignition switches Illinois corporate lawyer car accident lawyers controlled substance boating DUI Illinois injury lawyer filing a medical malpractice claim Barrington employment law firm Arlington Heights tax lawyer Schaumburg civil litigation attorney no contest clauses Colin H. Gilbert Palatine business attorney Barrington attorney trust payments ken apicella Rolling Meadows probate lawyer Illinois employment attorneys Palatine traffic lawyer Illinois employment law attorneys Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyer Illinois employment lawyer Schaumburg criminal attorney insurance claim denial Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorneys Illinois red light cameras slip and fall Illinois traffic attorneys jet ski forming a corporation in Illinois insurance dispute Illinois insurance disputes Crystal Lake employment law attorney Buffalo Grove personal injury lawyer Deer Park criminal attorney wills and trusts DUI penalities Deer Park accident attorney Illinois tax attorney Illinois attorney automated cars Palatine real estate lawyer Palatine Attorney Detainer Actions insurance denial appeals insurance dispute attorney rent to own real estate contracts liability claims car crashes pay when paid contract Chicago biking tips probate ObamaCare Do Not Resuscitate Buffalo Grove injury lawyer criminal defense pregnant women liens Palatine drug lawyer Employment Discrimination Law Riverwoods estate planning lawyer Buffalo Grove car accident lawyer underinsured motorist Rolling Meadows drug defense attorney Illinois bicycle safety independent contractor digital media accounts, estate planning, Arlington Heights estate planning attorney, insurance adjusters ACA breathalyzer test Crystal Lake car accident attorney employment contract, employment law, employment at-will, Deer Park employment law attorneys, contract, marijuana Barrington real estate lawyer estate planning guardianship attorney DNR Illinois traffic ticket lawyer Long Grove wills and trusts attorneys investment property bad faith insurance claims insurance disputes commercial leases Des Plaines real estate lawyer Illinois traffic attorney traffic accidents home inspection lawyer senior citizens Illinois insurance lawyer swimming pools Illinois personal injury attorney coronavirus Illinois collections attorney digital assets, digital fiduciary, estate planning, digital content, Long Grove estate planning lawyers insurance claim dispute Schaumburg medical malpractice lawyer Crystal Lake accident attorney dog bites Fair Labor Standards Act Thanksgiving mass shooting Schaumburg car accident attorney trustee defective products lawyer personal injury claims rumble strips Crystal Lake personal injury attorney trench injuries civil litigation Rolling Meadows employment law attorney Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers, insurance dispute criminal record Schaumburg employment attorney gift taxes installment contracts estate tax trauma after an accident income distribution deducation Illinois jet ski accident lawyer real estate closing brain injury Schaumburg probate attorney Schaumburg personal injury lawyer drug crimes lawyer Illinois car accident attorney expungement Family Medical Leave Act medical malpractice, missed diagnosis, delayed diagnosis, medical mistake, Deer Creek medical malpractice lawyers real estate zoning Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyer South Barrington real estate attorney vacation home fines startup company employees estate planning attorney murder charges Palatine personal injury lawyer agent Palatine probate lawyer Chicago lawyer premises liability digital information Deer Park DUI lawyer Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyers Illinois traffic accident lawyer fatal car accidents pedestrian accidents medication errors Arlington Heights personal injury lawyer landlord Rolling Meadows business lawyer Inverness elder law lawyer condo association Class A misdemeanor construction accidents, personal injury, wrongful death, Arlington Heights personal injury attorneys, workers' compensation natural gas explosion speeding Illinois trusts attorney Liquor Control Act Rolling Meadows traffic attorney field sobriety test trucking accident lawyers Palatine construction attorney creditors Illinois Human Rights Act gift tax exemption, estate planning, estate planning strategies, Illinois estate planning, South Barrington estate planning attorneys power of attorney for healthcare FMLA Inverness real estate attorney car crash injuries health insurance dispute Rolling Meadows insurance attorney pizza emoji Crystal Lake personal injury lawyer Chicago will attorney Crystal Lake medical malpractice law firm whistleblower protections special needs trust license suspension Palatine injury attorney employment law deadly crashes Illinois criminal defense attorney disability benefits Barrington medical malpractice lawyers spinal cord injury Home Sale Contingencies rest breaks golf accidents Rolling Meadows traffic law firm insurance claim delay Buffalo Grove corporate attorney Rolling Meadows DUI lawyer irrevocable trust hiring employees insurance negligence estate planning for college students financial advisors Des Plaines tax law firm Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act Crystal Lake insurance lawyer Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorney medical malpractice compensation foreclosure car collision Illinois registered agent estate plan real estate leasing Palatine criminal defense lawyer Illinois business law atorneys Barrington drug crime attorney Arlington Heights real estate lawyer traumatic brain injury estate planning lawyer motorcycle accident lawyer crossover accidents DGAA elder law Attorney Ken Apicella drug crime Illinois insurance dispute lawyers Buffalo Grove traffic attorney sexual images Crystal Lake tax lawyer pedestrian accident Schaumburg employment law attorneys Illinois employment law internet loopholes insurance attorney preventable medical errors in terrorem provision Schaumburg corporate attorney modern family estate planning insurance dispute, insurance dispute lawyers, insurance claim denial, insurance claim delays, Rolling Meadows insurance dispute attorneys Des Plaines personal injury lawyer Barrington employment attorney living trust benefits license reinstatement Palatine punch death real estate attorneys Retaliatory Discharge truck collisions employment law, Illinois employment laws Illinois employee rights attorney. Schaumburg wrongful death attorney Palatine civil attorney POA surgical mistakes denied insurance claim traffic violations Illinois employment laws Arlington Heights TBI attorney Crystal lake insurance dispute attorney Rolling Meadows insurance lawyer Rolling Meadows Traffic Lawyer Arlington Heights injury attorney Des Plaines claims law firm caregiver Deer Park traffic accident attorney Illinois living will Illinois pedestrian accident attorney Illinois workplace lawyer Rolling Meadows criminal attorney appealing an insurance claim revenge porn probate fees life insurance claims Rolling Meadows employment law attorneys estate planning, digital assets, Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, Illinois digital assets, Illinois estate planning, privacy advance healthcare directive Rolling Meadows marijuana attorney Illinois wrongful termination lawyer Rolling Meadows car accident lawyers Deer Park employment law attorney cell phone power of attorney Deer Park personal injury lawyer Palatine civil litigation lawyer personal injury Illinois traffic laws sexual harassment attorney fees Inverness DUI lawyer Illinois Trust Code right to work Chicago insurance law firm Schaumburg Attorney Crystal Lake employment lawyer denial of life insurance driving Palatine elder law attorney Illinois Smoke Detector Act slip and fall accidents severance agreements dealing with problem employees Chicago will attorney, social media platforms, Illinois estate planning lawyer, Illinois Transfer on Death Instrument Rolling Meadows Attorney Arlington Heights car crash attorneys Illinois defective products attorney insurance claim Buffalo Grove probate lawyer Schaumburg real estate lawyer Illinois estate planning law firm Barrington personal injury lawyer Barrington boating accident attorney Schaumburg traffic lawyer Chicago insurance claim attorneys wills TBI medical malpractice claims DUI defense Rolling Meadows Illinois job attorney Arlington Heights trucking lawyer Super Mario boating under the influence Illinois personal injury lawyers texting and driving murder defense Illinois estate planning Barrington civil litigation attorney Illinois medical malpractice lawyers Palatine corporate law attorneys Food and Drug Administration's Food Safety Modernization Act Arlington Heights personal injury attorney bicycle dooring accidents changes to mortgage law probate lawyer Legal Info Rolling Meadows corporate lawyer pedestrian-automobile accident work unions real estate texting while driving pedestrian injuries, pedestrian fatality Crystal Lake medical malpractice lawyer Crystal Lake employment attorney Illinois civil litigation lawyer Palatine trusts lawyer hands free device DUI insurance claim dispute attorney Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act vacation home Palatine corporate attorney Deer Park traffic lawyer product liability Des Plaines injury law firm personal injury, auto accident injuries, delayed injuries, serious injuries, Des Plaines personal injury attorneys Chicago car accident lawyer Crystal Lake car accident lawyer Des Plaines collections attorney head on collisions owner responsibility Arlington Heights employment law attorneys Des Plaines insurance attorney life insurance caretaker rights Illinois will lawyer Fourth of July paid sick leave wage theft Crystal Lake traffic lawyer Des Plaines Traffic Lawyer Crystal Lake law firm Buffalo Grove insurance claim dispute lawyers personal injury attorney Buffalo Grove traffic lawyers underage DUI Long Grove estate planning attorney cell phone accidents living trust vs will insurance disputes, Illinois insurance disputes, Illinois insurance dispute attorneys, denied insurance claims, Arlington Heights insurance dispute attorneys job lawyers spinal cord injuries workers comp commercial leasing fiduciary rule delay Palatine workers compensation lawyer Long Grove estate planning Illinois real estate Barrington workers compensation attorney pain and suffering license revocation corporate law Crystal Lake bike accident lawyer Barrington employment law attorney landlord tenant law Crystal Lake civil litigation lawyer Palatine employment lawyer Inverness personal injury attorney life insurance policy unfunded trust bike accident traffic tickets traffic deaths FSLA Illinois employment law firm Barrington estate planning lawyer Illinois workers compensation attorney Exclusions DMV bicycle accidents Illinois personal injury lawyer Policy Cancellation clemency uninsured motorist fiduciary rule Schaumburg estate planning attorney Des Plaines DUI attorney Barrington Illinois estate planning lawyer Illinois wills and trusts Illinois LLC creation deed transfer residential real estate overtime pay Inverness corporate attorney workplace sexual harassment medical malpractice Inverness civil lawyer Crystal Lake criminal defense attorney Schaumburg insurance lawyers involuntary manslaughter insurance agent negligence IRS IRA benefits Long Grove estate planning attorneys Des Plaines motorcycle accident attorney estate planning trusts drunk driving statistics Illinois probate lawyer Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyer personal injury law firm contracts Palatine insurance lawyer Des Plaines Long Grove real estate lawyer Arlington Heights pedestrian accidents dynasty trusts Joliet general practice lawyers federal crimes Arlington Heights insurance attorney anesthesia errors Inverness probate lawyer taxes hit and run accident distracted driving accident victims BAIID Colin Gilbert Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyers icy parking lots Jay Andrew Des Plaines civil attorney natural gas Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission real estate contract Palatine traffic accidents foreclosed rental property Illinois criminal law Schaumburg personal injury claim underfunded trust LLCs Barrington Traffic Lawyer Chicago estate planning reckless homicide Arlington Heights Traffic Lawyer Des Plaines real estate attorney Illinois medical malpractice case employment lawyer Illinois employment law attorney overtime violations Inverness traffic law firm Palatine employment law lawyer Illinois DUI attorney insurance claims Des Plaines drug lawyer Arlington Heights lawyer Illinois lawyer marijuana crimes attorney School Visitation Rights Act construction contracts Rolling Meadows personal injury attorney insurance claim denials traffic violations defense civil rights violation Chicago trucking accident attorney eluding a police officer Illinois estate planning attorney employment law, meal breaks, rest breaks, hotel employees, Des Plaines employment law attorneys Barrington estate planning attorney employment attorney Illinois insurance claims lawyers Palatine law firm Palatine employment attorney Chicago corporate attorney Des Plaines personal injury attorney Chicago traffic lawyer new real estate form privacy laws commercial real estate drugs Buffalo Grove law firm digital assets pet law Rolling Meadows litigation lawyer blended families Schaumburg estate attorney nursing home negligence Rolling Meadows accident lawyer Deer Park workers compensation lawyer car accident lawyer college kids Crystal Lake estate planning lawyer workers compensation Illinois pet lawyer blood alcohol content Deer Park medical malpractice attorney Schaumburg personal injury lawyers healthcare claims wrongful termination Schaumburg personal injury attorney Mount Prospect wills and trusts lawyers employee discrimination distracted driving accidents Illinois elder law attorney small business preventing accidents Mt Prospect Attorney Illinois business lawyer trucking accidents comparative negligence Rolling Meadows real estate attorney DUI attorney trusts Chicago attorney sole proprietorship wrongful termination, employment law, whistleblower protections, Illinois employment laws, discrimination in the workplace Illinois Sales Representative Act Illinois driving without license Des Plaines accident attorney Illinois speeding lawyer car accident Illinois workers compensation lawyer denied insurance claims insurance denials workers compensation benefits living wills Illinois workplace discrimination attorney traffic laws healthcare Mount Prospect real estate lawyer mortgage Rolling Meadows estate planning attorney Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyers employment contract Illinois small business institutional trustee Schaumburg estate planning lawyer Rolling Meadows criminal lawyer BAC medical research Buffalo Grove medical malpractice lawyers Barrington criminal defense lawyer insurance agents rollover accidents Self-Directed IRA Accounts traffic crimes Affordable Care Act Des Plaines criminal attorney drunk driving real estate attorney Illinois personal injury probate claims problem employees Schaumburg criminal law attorney