Employee Misclassification and Why It Matters

Web Admin - Monday, March 30, 2015

employment contract, Illinois employment law lawyerThe relationship between employers and employees comes with many legal complexities, and there are times when employers can improperly curtail employees' rights, either by accident or design. One common place where this sort of issue arises is through employee misclassification, the practice of designating an employee as an independent contractor. Although the decision of which of those classes a worker falls into is one for a court to decide, many employers choose to make an improper classification in order to avoid having to provide things like overtime pay or workers' compensation insurance.

What Misclassification Is

There are two classes of worker for many employment law purposes: employees and independent contractors. Generally speaking, the difference between the two is the amount of control that an employer exercises over them. The more control, the more likely the court is to find that an employer/employee relationship exists. However, there are actually a variety of factors that courts look to, including:

  • - How much direction the employer gives in how to complete tasks;
  • - The type of evaluation system the worker operates under;
  • - Whether the business trains the worker;
  • - Whether the business reimburses the worker's expenses;
  • - Whether the worker can work for other employers;
  • - How the worker is paid;
  • - Whether the relationship is intended to be long-term; and
  • - Whether the worker's services are a key part of the business.

Examples can often be helpful to understand whether someone qualifies as an employee or an independent contractor. For instance, a secretary working at an office for years probably qualifies as an employee because of the high amount of control the employer would retain, as well as the other factors. Conversely, an IT worker hired to set up the company's network would probably be an independent contractor because they are going about the work in their own way, and the job's duration is limited.

Why It Matters

This distinction matters because it affects the responsibility that an employer has towards the worker. Many of the legal protections afforded to workers are only given to people in an employer/employee relationship. For instance, many employers misclassify their employees in order to avoid paying overtime pay or to avoid providing workers' compensation insurance. They can also use misclassification to shift tax burdens onto the worker, by avoiding things like unemployment insurance and Social Security taxes.

A worker's classification is a matter for courts to decide, and how an employer has elected to treat the worker is immaterial. If you believe that you have been misclassified and are losing access to benefits like overtime pay or workers' compensation benefits, contact an experienced Illinois employment lawyer today. Drost, Gilbert, Andrew & Apicella, LLC serves workers in many northwest suburban towns, such as Rolling Meadows, Schaumburg, Inverness, Deer Park, and Arlington Heights.

Ken ApicellaAbout the Author: Attorney Ken Apicella is a founding partner of DGAA focusing in the areas of personal injury, employment, insurance coverage disputes, and civil litigation. Ken earned his J.D. from DePaul University College of Law in 1999. He has been named a SuperLawyers Rising Star and a Forty Illinois Attorneys Under Forty to Watch. Ken has written and lectured for the Illinois Institute for Continuing Legal Education and regularly serves as a moderator at Northwest Suburban Bar Association's Continuing Legal Education seminars.

Recent Posts


Inverness elder law lawyer Fair Labor Standards Act Palatine punch death trauma after an accident Schaumburg estate planning attorney Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act Rolling Meadows Attorney premises liability motorcycle accident lawyer sexual harassment slip and fall accidents Buffalo Grove employment lawyer Illinois DUI attorney personal injury claims Barrington estate planning lawyer insurance agents marijuana employee rights coronavirus caretaker rights Rolling Meadows DUI lawyer filing a medical malpractice claim driving DUI penalities Barrington medical malpractice lawyers Des Plaines motorcycle accident attorney Illinois workers compensation lawyer insurance claim dispute DNR Rolling Meadows real estate attorney IRS Illinois workers compensation attorney DUI attorney Rolling Meadows traffic attorney Thanksgiving Barrington personal injury lawyer Illinois medical malpractice attorney Illinois insurance dispute lawyers Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyer mortgage Barrington criminal lawyer fatal car accidents federal crimes BAIID Palatine personal injury lawyer Buffalo Grove corporate attorney employment attorney construction accidents, personal injury, wrongful death, Arlington Heights personal injury attorneys, workers' compensation Des Plaines personal injury attorney social media after death Illinois workplace lawyer product liability college kids severance agreements Deer Park medical malpractice attorney traffic accidents Illinois civil litigation lawyer Illinois construction accident attorney Joliet general practice lawyers Riverwoods estate planning lawyer blood alcohol content estate tax Schaumburg insurance lawyers elder law digital assets Arlington Heights pedestrian accidents Food and Drug Administration's Food Safety Modernization Act Attorney Ken Apicella traffic violations defense car collision estate planning attorney brain injury denied insurance claims Buffalo Grove traffic attorney murder deed transfer Crystal Lake business law attorneys trench injuries internet Arlington Heights trucking lawyer Illinois driving without license Arlington Heights employment attorney Illinois registered agent Illinois Trust Code Barrington Illinois estate planning lawyer Buffalo Grove traffic lawyers insurance claim delay Crystal Lake medical malpractice law firm Inverness insurance attorney Deer Park DUI lawyer Crystal Lake employment attorney Do Not Resuscitate motorcycle accident cell phone tower data Deer Park criminal attorney Deer Park motorcycle accident lawyer BUI Rolling Meadows boating crash lawyer traffic crimes living trust Rolling Meadows criminal lawyer breach of contract workplace sexual harassment Super Mario Inverness probate lawyer Des Plaines DUI attorney Palatine drug lawyer car accident lawyer manufacturing Detainer Actions Rolling Meadows criminal attorney Inverness accident lawyer Schaumburg drug defense lawyer insurance claim dispute attorney Des Plaines civil attorney products liability Illinois living will Illinois collections attorney real estate closing problem employees Barrington employment law attorney medical research preventing accidents ObamaCare pedestrian injuries, pedestrian fatality Long Grove estate planning Inverness civil lawyer modern family estate planning Palatine civil attorney Chicago estate planning Illinois corporate lawyer Palatine corporate law attorneys Chicago insurance claim attorneys Chicago will attorney, social media platforms, Illinois estate planning lawyer, Schaumburg corporate attorney Schaumburg Attorney fault based insurance Des Plaines collections attorney Inverness traffic law firm Des Plaines Traffic Lawyer Rolling Meadows employment attorney deadly crashes car crashes Barrington criminal defense lawyer Kenilworth estate planning lawyer controlled substance Crystal Lake bike accident lawyer digital evidence pet bites natural gas criminal defense IRELA truck collisions automated cars civil litigation wrongful death Palatine workers compensation lawyer personal injury IRA benefits in terrorem provision income distribution deducation Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyers Illinois elder law attorney senior citizens drug possession Buffalo Grove law firm Retaliatory Discharge CAM Arlington Heights medical malpractice lawyer FMLA personal injury, auto accident injuries, delayed injuries, serious injuries, Des Plaines personal injury attorneys suspended license installment contracts golf accidents DUI defense probate claims license llinois Real Estate Lawyers Association Kenilworth estate planning attorneys personal injury attorney hit and run accident Schaumburg elder law lawyer Policy Cancellation probate Legal Info criminal boating under the influence Crystal Lake insurance lawyer Schaumburg estate planning lawyer fiduciary rule delay Illinois personal injury Palatine employment lawyer tax attorney slip and fall pain and suffering corporate law bicycle accidents Illinois speeding lawyer Chicago employment lawyer food poisoning unauthorized overtime Illinois business lawyer Schaumburg employment law attorneys medical malpractice, missed diagnosis, delayed diagnosis, medical mistake, Deer Creek medical malpractice lawyers unfunded trust Illinois job attorney Chicago estate planning lawyer federal regulations for LLCs attorney fees medical malpractice compensation Crystal Lake will lawyer rent to own real estate contracts Illinois law Schaumburg traffic lawyer Des Plaines claims law firm Illinois lawyer insurance claim medication errors Illinois employment law Schaumburg probate attorney advance healthcare directive Schaumburg employment attorney commercial leases Illinois employment laws Inverness estate planning lawyer revenge porn Barrington boating accident attorney Colin Gilbert cell phone Palatine probate lawyer Rolling Meadows Illinois Sales Representative Act Illinois medical malpractice claim traffic offenses Palatine insurance lawyer rumble strips insurance agent negligence Chicago corporate attorney Des Plaines drug crimes lawyer head on collisions speeding Barrington business law firm Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyer Inverness injury lawyer insurance dispute, insurance dispute lawyers, insurance claim denial, insurance claim delays, Rolling Meadows insurance dispute attorneys liability ken apicella insurance claim denials construction accidents employee discrimination holiday statistics Long Grove estate planning attorneys trusts Deer Park employment law attorney Palatine traffic lawyer Crystal Lake personal injury lawyer child safety employment law, meal breaks, rest breaks, hotel employees, Des Plaines employment law attorneys underfunded trust Rolling Meadows corporate lawyer appealing an insurance claim medical malpractice claims Rolling Meadows accident lawyer Crystal Lake medical malpractice lawyer hiring employees Barrington civil litigation attorney workers comp PTSD Illinois traffic attorneys Kenilworth estate planning attorney expungement Arlington Heights estate planning attorney first degree murder insurance claim denial underage DUI Chicago insurance law firm Illinois business law atorneys comparative negligence Illinois traffic laws bicycle dooring accidents Schaumburg estate attorney power of attorney life insurance claims condo Barrington litigation attorney low-ball insurance settlement operating agreements Illinois employee rights attorney. distracted driving accident victims personal injury lawyer Arlington Heights personal injury lawyer blended families taxes eluding a police officer pedestrian-automobile accident Arlington Heights lawyer foreclosed rental property estate attorney Illinois medical malpractice case Illinois employment lawyer LLCs startup company Palatine corporate attorney Arlington Heights TBI attorney Crystal Lake civil litigation lawyer Forcible Entry power of attorney for healthcare car crash Crystal Lake tax lawyer Des Plaines tax law firm estate planning, death tax, succession plans, business estate plans, Barrington estate planning lawyers sole proprietorship Barrington personal injury attorney auto accidents pedestrian accidents Illinois insurance claims lawyers Illinois traffic ticket lawyer Crystal Lake personal injury attorney Crystal Lake injury attorney Rolling Meadows Traffic Lawyer Arlington Heights car crash attorneys Buffalo Grove medical malpractice lawyers Chicago trucking accident attorney car accidents employment lawyer POA forming a corporation in Illinois civil litigation attorney Home Remodeling Repair Act probate fees real estate leasing dealing with problem employees IRA trust transfer Arlington Heights employment law attorneys Palatine injury attorney Illinois jet ski accident lawyer preventable medical errors pet law Fourth of July car accident agent pedestrian accident Home Sale Contingencies living trust vs will Illinois employment law firm small business Schaumburg criminal attorney Schaumburg wrongful death attorney Illinois small business Illinois home inspection landlord tenant law Chicago attorney GM ignition switches loss of consortium criminal record Schaumburg criminal law attorney wrongful termination, employment law, whistleblower protections, Illinois employment laws, discrimination in the workplace real estate contract back injuries consent to a search Illinois insurance claim attorney Chicago traffic lawyer Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorney Long Grove real estate lawyer hands free device Illinois estate planning attorney Illinois red light cameras Des Plaines injury law firm Illinois LLC creation comp time Des Plaines drunk driving statistics fiduciary rule wage theft Buffalo Grove probate lawyer Inverness real estate attorney Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyer Rolling Meadows traffic law firm Illinois insurance disputes Exclusions Schaumburg civil litigation attorney distracted driving accidents elder abuse Arlington Heights traffic attorney reckless homicide Chicago biking tips ACA icy parking lots Des Plaines drug lawyer personal injury law firm personal injury accidents disability benefits trucking accidents estate planning subcontractor rollover car crashes liability claims Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorneys Rolling Meadows insurance lawyer South Barrington real estate lawyer drug crime Illinois real estate Schaumburg real estate lawyer vacation home fines trust payments involuntary manslaughter Illinois Smoke Detector Act Mount Prospect wills and trusts lawyers Colin H. Gilbert Barrington estate planning attorney real estate zoning real estate attorneys Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act personal injury claim employment contract, employment law, employment at-will, Deer Park employment law attorneys, contract, Des Plaines accident attorney Rolling Meadows drug defense attorney Rolling Meadows personal injury attorney Barrington injury attorney Palatine real estate lawyer Deer Park traffic lawyer Long Grove wills and trusts attorneys Liquor Control Act BAC Rolling Meadows employment law attorney Inverness personal injury attorney Buffalo Grove car accident lawyer trucking accident lawyers Palatine criminal defense lawyer dram shop law Barrington workers compensation attorney overtime pay insurance denial appeals Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers, insurance dispute Schaumburg personal injury lawyer natural gas explosion license suspension Barrington attorney compensatory time real estate overtime violations traffic violations Barrington employment attorney Illinois wrongful termination lawyer employment law Des Plaines criminal attorney cell phone accidents Des Plaines personal injury lawyers job lawyers Illinois employment attorneys School Visitation Rights Act digital media accounts, estate planning, Arlington Heights estate planning attorney, no contest clauses accidental death benefits license reinstatement Illinois personal injury attorney sexual images Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorneys unpaid assessment DUI Des Plaines insurance attorney traffic deaths real estate lawyer Palatine Attorney Illinois Transfer on Death Instrument Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyers Palatine employment law lawyer Illinois Illinois defective products attorney Barrington real estate lawyer murder charges mass shooting Arlington Heights tax lawyer estate planning trusts Crystal Lake accident attorney Palatine business attorney independent contractor employment law, Illinois employment laws Chicago car accident lawyer institutional trustee Illinois Human Rights Act privacy Transfer on Death Instrument clemency anesthesia errors denial of life insurance changes to mortgage law special needs trust Rolling Meadows employment law attorneys Illinois trucking safety living trust benefits spinal cord injuries license revocation trustee living wills Inverness corporate attorney Crystal Lake employment lawyer minimum wage Class A misdemeanor Crystal Lake car accident lawyer boating accidents employees jet ski Barrington Traffic Lawyer underinsured motorist Crystal Lake estate planning lawyer unpaid overtime condo association Illinois real estate lawyer dog bites Crystal lake insurance dispute attorney Rolling Meadows insurance attorney Deer Park workers compensation lawyer Arlington Heights insurance attorney Illinois pet lawyer paid sick leave meal breaks life insurance policy Illinois mortgages medical marijuana Mount Prospect elder law attorney traumatic brain injuries construction contracts jet ski accidents Illinois bicycle safety Rolling Meadows tax attorney financial advisors Illinois boating accident lawyer real estate attorney Arlington Heights Traffic Lawyer insurance negligence wills and trusts Illinois wills and trusts attorneys Barrington employment law firm Illinois probate lawyer Crystal Lake traffic lawyer whistleblower protections Illinois estate planning Inverness real estate lawyer Crystal Lake pet attorney Arlington Heights car accident lawyer Rolling Meadows estate planning attorney car crash injuries business litigation Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers health insurance dispute Schaumburg personal injury attorney rest breaks foreclosure right to work drugs probate lawyer DMV creditors irrevocable trust digital assets, digital fiduciary, estate planning, digital content, Long Grove estate planning lawyers Palatine law firm Illinois car accident attorney traumatic brain injury drug crimes lawyer TBI home inspection lawyer Crystal Lake traffic attorney Employment Discrimination Law bad faith insurance claims insurance adjusters estate planning for college students marijuana crimes attorney Illinois personal injury lawyer estate planning lawyer capital gains tax workers compensation benefits insurance disputes, Illinois insurance disputes, Illinois insurance dispute attorneys, denied insurance claims, Arlington Heights insurance dispute attorneys Buffalo Grove personal injury lawyer Mount Prospect real estate lawyer Long Grove estate planning attorney insurance denials uninsured motorist Illinois wills and trusts healthcare Illinois estate planning law firm Palatine employment attorney car accident lawyers employee misclassification Rolling Meadows business lawyer Inverness DUI lawyer Deer Park traffic accident attorney Illinois employment law attorney contracts Illinois pedestrian accident attorney Chicago lawyer wills swimming pools surgical mistakes bike accident South Barrington real estate attorney Illinois insurance attorney Family Medical Leave Act gift tax exemption, estate planning, estate planning strategies, Illinois estate planning, South Barrington estate planning attorneys Illinois motorcycle accident lawyer denied insurance claim Illinois employment law attorneys crossover accidents Deer Park real estate law firm Arlington Heights accident attorney FSLA owner responsibility pregnant women traffic tickets Rolling Meadows litigation lawyer Illinois injury lawyer Schaumburg car accident attorney Illinois criminal defense attorney Schaumburg personal injury lawyers DGAA Crystal Lake law firm Landlord Tenant Ordinance Palatine traffic accidents Palatine estate planning lawyer Rolling Meadows probate lawyer Illinois Probate Act of 1975 workers compensation field sobriety test Buffalo Grove personal injury attorney Crystal Lake criminal defense attorney Illinois insurance lawyer Illinois medical malpractice lawyers medical malpractice Chicago employment attorney Whistleblower Claims Illinois personal injury lawyers landlord spinal cord injury traffic laws work unions drunk driving commercial real estate Long Grove real estate attorney Deer Park accident attorney residential real estate Barrington drug crime attorney Des Plaines real estate attorney Illinois tax attorney Crystal Lake pedestrian accident lawyer Illinois rollover accident lawyers texting and driving Des Plaines pet law attorney Rolling Meadows car accident lawyers investment property Illinois traffic accident lawyer Schaumburg medical malpractice lawyer Illinois trusts attorney new real estate form texting while driving Des Plaines real estate lawyer Buffalo Grove criminal defense lawyer insurance dispute attorney civil rights violation estate plan wrongful termination Illinois workplace discrimination attorney rollover accidents insurance dispute nursing home negligence drug crimes probate process probate claims process employment contract Affordable Care Act Arlington Heights real estate lawyer Deer Park personal injury lawyer Illinois traffic attorney Buffalo Grove insurance claim dispute lawyers estate planning, digital assets, Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, Illinois digital assets, Illinois estate planning, Schaumburg construction accident lawyer homestead rights dynasty trusts commercial leasing Palatine elder law attorney Palatine civil litigation lawyer insurance attorney healthcare claims guardianship attorney Schaumburg liens Arlington Heights personal injury attorney Self-Directed IRA Accounts digital information Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission pizza emoji insurance disputes Palatine trusts lawyer Illinois will lawyer breathalyzer test Palatine construction attorney Rolling Meadows marijuana attorney caregiver Rolling Meadows medical malpractice lawyers Crystal Lake employment law attorney boating DUI insurance claims life insurance Crystal Lake car accident attorney Chicago will attorney Arlington Heights criminal lawyer Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyers defective products lawyer Jay Andrew defective products life insurance lawyer Illinois attorney Schaumburg injury lawyer gift taxes Arlington Heights Attorney Des Plaines medical malpractice attorney criminal law murder defense loopholes Des Plaines personal injury lawyer vacation home pay when paid contract Arlington Heights injury attorney Mt Prospect Attorney privacy laws Buffalo Grove real estate attorney Buffalo Grove injury lawyer