Study Finds Most Doctors Are Confused by Living Wills

Web Admin - Friday, February 24, 2017

Barrington medical malpractice lawyersLiving wills are, quite literally, a matter of life and death. They are also fairly common documents, which means doctors and surgeons should know how to interpret them. Yet a recent study has determined that, much of the time, they interpret these documents incorrectly. Besides having the wishes expressed in their living will violated, what might this mean for patients and their families? The following explains. 

A Closer Look at the Study

Published in the Journal of Patient Safety, the recent study asked 741 physicians from 13 different hospitals to detail how they would treat nine different patients with varying degrees of cardiopulmonary distress, based on what they understood from the patients’ living wills. They only reached a consensus (defined as agreement of 95 percent or higher) in two out of the nine scenarios. If they viewed a one-minute video that expressed each patient’s wishes, along with reading the living will, they reached a 94 percent agreement on a third patient. 

What was most disturbing about this is that, out of those remaining cases, many doctors got the answer wrong. Some would have given too much treatment to a patient who did not want specific life-saving procedures and practices. Others would have given too little treatment, potentially placing the patient at risk for death when they wanted life-saving practices and procedures. The implications of either are concerning, to say the least. 

What Happens When Doctors Misinterpret Living Wills

Patients who have a do-not-resuscitate (DNR) in place typically have one for a particular reason. Perhaps they simply do not want to risk the chances of being left in a vegetative state, or making their families decide when to pull the plug. Others may have chronic and debilitating conditions that are eroding their health. 

In contrast, patients who want certain life-saving procedures and practices have reasons for wanting to live. Maybe they have children, or are simply okay with certain practices but not others. They can express these specific wishes through their living will. Yet, if they are not interpreted correctly, patients and their families may experience a wrongful death, or a situation where they are revived and forced to live in a way they might not wanted (i.e. being in a comatose state or on life support). Both situations could pave the way for a medical malpractice lawsuit. 

Contact Our Barrington Medical Malpractice Lawyers

If you or someone you love has experienced wrongful death or improper treatment, despite having a living will in place, the experienced Barrington medical malpractice attorneys at Drost, Gilbert, Andrew & Apicella, LLC can help. Dedicated and experienced, we will fight for the most compensation possible in your case. Learn more by calling 847-934-6000 today.

Ken ApicellaAbout the Author: Attorney Ken Apicella is a founding partner of DGAA focusing in the areas of personal injury, employment, insurance coverage disputes, and civil litigation. Ken earned his J.D. from DePaul University College of Law in 1999. He has been named a SuperLawyers Rising Star and a Forty Illinois Attorneys Under Forty to Watch. Ken has written and lectured for the Illinois Institute for Continuing Legal Education and regularly serves as a moderator at Northwest Suburban Bar Association's Continuing Legal Education seminars.


Recent Posts


most common reasons for life insurance claim denials material misrepresentation Des Plaines real estate lawyer surgical mistakes in terrorem provision foreclosure residential real estate liens Arlington Heights Traffic Lawyer Illinois driving without license clemency Illinois business law atorneys Rolling Meadows probate lawyer employment contract Illinois insurance attorney Des Plaines Illinois employee rights attorney. Illinois insurance claims lawyers Illinois motorcycle accident lawyer trucking accidents Schaumburg car accident attorney Rolling Meadows criminal attorney life insurance policy small business contracts Schaumburg estate planning attorney Illinois lawyer Palatine estate planning lawyer Rolling Meadows traffic law firm Illinois insurance lawyer Palatine life insurance lawyer Barrington Illinois estate planning lawyer products liability Schaumburg personal injury lawyer Rolling Meadows employment law attorneys insurance dispute attorney real estate trusts Affordable Care Act probate process Crystal Lake traffic lawyer drugs guardianship attorney Fair Labor Standards Act social media after death Liquor Control Act Schaumburg personal injury lawyers probate lawyer insurance disputes employee misclassification Rolling Meadows insurance lawyer drug crime Buffalo Grove employment lawyer Crystal Lake pet attorney fatal car accidents Colin H. Gilbert homestead rights drunk driving statistics privacy traffic offenses Illinois pet lawyer insurance denials Mount Prospect wills and trusts lawyers Crystal Lake employment lawyer Inverness elder law lawyer life insurance Palatine business attorney drug possession hit and run accident Barrington employment law firm bad faith insurance claims rollover car crashes Des Plaines motorcycle accident attorney FMLA first degree murder distracted driving accident victims Barrington personal injury lawyer Crystal Lake business law attorneys foreclosed rental property real estate zoning employee discrimination filing a medical malpractice claim Crystal Lake personal injury lawyer Crystal Lake car accident lawyer Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorneys healthcare claims Riverwoods estate planning lawyer wrongful death civil rights violation loopholes taxes Schaumburg traffic lawyer Palatine employment attorney Illinois corporate lawyer drunk driving Arlington Heights real estate lawyer Illinois speeding lawyer elder law Illinois attorney Long Grove estate planning insufficient documentation wrongful termination underfunded trust condo Arlington Heights lawyer medical malpractice compensation TBI workers compensation benefits Jay Andrew minimum wage Palatine workers compensation lawyer insurance dispute, insurance dispute lawyers, insurance claim denial, insurance claim delays, Rolling Meadows insurance dispute attorneys Palatine employment lawyer Inverness probate lawyer medical research insurance adjusters denied insurance claim marijuana DMV criminal defense changes to mortgage law Food and Drug Administration's Food Safety Modernization Act hiring employees federal crimes gift tax exemption, estate planning, estate planning strategies, Illinois estate planning, South Barrington estate planning attorneys Des Plaines claims law firm Rolling Meadows accident lawyer pet bites Illinois red light cameras Illinois workplace lawyer probate claims process Des Plaines real estate attorney trustee DUI defense dog bites employment lawyer Illinois trusts attorney Schaumburg estate planning lawyer Buffalo Grove life insurance attorney defective products lawyer Schaumburg elder law lawyer personal injury claims underage DUI estate planning attorney Rolling Meadows DUI lawyer swimming pools Palatine probate lawyer coronavirus estate planning trusts Illinois personal injury attorney Palatine employment law lawyer Transfer on Death Instrument Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission Illinois LLC creation Rolling Meadows employment attorney Crystal Lake employment attorney denied insurance claims preventing accidents no contest clauses traumatic brain injury Barrington personal injury attorney Chicago estate planning creditors Palatine trusts lawyer Buffalo Grove medical malpractice lawyers Rolling Meadows tax attorney car accidents Chicago employment attorney Super Mario Schaumburg estate attorney Long Grove estate planning attorneys Arlington Heights estate planning attorney liability claims Arlington Heights car crash attorneys premises liability boating accidents real estate closing Crystal Lake civil litigation lawyer hands free device new real estate form dynasty trusts Crystal Lake medical malpractice lawyer IRELA Inverness civil lawyer expungement Illinois employment law attorney car collision institutional trustee sexual harassment Crystal Lake accident attorney Illinois pedestrian accident attorney Chicago car accident lawyer Home Sale Contingencies operating agreements jet ski accidents ObamaCare Illinois car accident attorney Barrington civil litigation attorney Rolling Meadows employment law attorney Rolling Meadows real estate attorney ken apicella controlled substance employment attorney Deer Park DUI lawyer dram shop law workers comp South Barrington real estate lawyer Des Plaines accident attorney Illinois real estate Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyer paid sick leave Des Plaines criminal attorney Crystal Lake medical malpractice attorneys Illinois civil litigation lawyer civil litigation attorney Illinois Smoke Detector Act Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act Illinois registered agent Illinois Trust Code Rolling Meadows litigation lawyer real estate leasing wrongful termination, employment law, whistleblower protections, Illinois employment laws, discrimination in the workplace digital assets, digital fiduciary, estate planning, digital content, Long Grove estate planning lawyers uninsured motorist Inverness accident lawyer BUI Illinois Transfer on Death Instrument Barrington employment attorney Rolling Meadows blood alcohol content pedestrian accidents Attorney Ken Apicella severance agreements estate tax Buffalo Grove car accident lawyer Des Plaines personal injury lawyer boating under the influence Rolling Meadows insurance attorney automated cars denial of life insurance Schaumburg injury lawyer personal injury lawyer employment law, meal breaks, rest breaks, hotel employees, Des Plaines employment law attorneys Schaumburg insurance lawyers Illinois workers compensation attorney Arlington Heights wills and trusts attorney Illinois traffic ticket lawyer personal injury law firm unpaid overtime bicycle accidents Barrington criminal lawyer caretaker rights Arlington Heights TBI attorney Rolling Meadows traffic attorney Schaumburg drug defense lawyer traffic deaths Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyer holiday statistics Des Plaines personal injury attorney Deer Park accident attorney Schaumburg construction accident lawyer medical malpractice, missed diagnosis, delayed diagnosis, medical mistake, Deer Creek medical malpractice lawyers car crash modern family estate planning Retaliatory Discharge Barrington estate planning lawyer IRA benefits Crystal Lake injury attorney Chicago traffic lawyer Arlington Heights trucking lawyer work unions estate planning, digital assets, Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, Illinois digital assets, Illinois estate planning, pedestrian-automobile accident FSLA Arlington Heights personal injury lawyer elder abuse CAM Chicago insurance claim attorneys icy parking lots product liability Chicago life insurance attorney Illinois collections attorney forming a corporation in Illinois Chicago attorney estate planning for college students internet Long Grove real estate lawyer Chicago corporate attorney Chicago insurance law firm back injuries Arlington Heights insurance attorney Rolling Meadows estate planning attorney Buffalo Grove insurance claim dispute lawyers Illinois real estate lawyer jet ski Crystal Lake car accident attorney gift taxes living trust benefits Schaumburg medical malpractice lawyer Policy Cancellation Rolling Meadows personal injury attorney probate fees Buffalo Grove law firm revenge porn Illinois insurance dispute lawyers insurance claim denials financial advisors head on collisions Illinois job attorney GM ignition switches spinal cord injuries fault based insurance insurance dispute Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers construction accidents, personal injury, wrongful death, Arlington Heights personal injury attorneys, workers' compensation Long Grove estate planning attorney Buffalo Grove traffic attorney Inverness corporate attorney Illinois workers compensation lawyer power of attorney natural gas Chicago trucking accident attorney Forcible Entry probate Illinois Human Rights Act Illinois insurance claim dispute lawyers employee rights Barrington Traffic Lawyer Chicago will attorney Buffalo Grove personal injury lawyer texting and driving Arlington Heights accident attorney trust payments Crystal Lake tax lawyer Detainer Actions estate planning pizza emoji cause-of-death exclusions Arlington Heights employment attorney criminal record car accident lawyers texting while driving traumatic brain injuries license Buffalo Grove traffic lawyers Barrington life insurance lawyer Inverness DUI lawyer anesthesia errors landlord tenant law Des Plaines pet law attorney senior citizens Palatine criminal defense lawyer Des Plaines tax law firm special needs trust Illinois probate lawyer real estate lawyer insurance disputes, Illinois insurance disputes, Illinois insurance dispute attorneys, denied insurance claims, Arlington Heights insurance dispute attorneys Barrington real estate lawyer probate claims Des Plaines drug crimes lawyer Chicago biking tips personal injury claim Palatine insurance lawyer Illinois jet ski accident lawyer top life insurance claim denials Arlington Heights wills and trusts lawyers medical malpractice Palatine civil attorney LLCs sexual images IRS Rolling Meadows criminal lawyer DUI attorney speeding Rolling Meadows medical malpractice lawyers Rolling Meadows Attorney Illinois small business Chicago will attorney, social media platforms, Illinois estate planning lawyer, Palatine traffic lawyer Schaumburg corporate attorney employees IRA trust transfer Chicago estate planning lawyer digital evidence trench injuries Arlington Heights personal injury attorney disability benefits personal injury, auto accident injuries, delayed injuries, serious injuries, Des Plaines personal injury attorneys Illinois bicycle safety Arlington Heights medical malpractice lawyer Inverness injury lawyer Inverness estate planning lawyer insurance agent negligence insurance agents civil litigation Illinois business lawyer traffic tickets Barrington injury attorney Illinois employment law firm Des Plaines injury law firm Illinois traffic attorney spinal cord injury Chicago employment lawyer attorney fees unfunded trust unauthorized overtime Palatine Attorney Des Plaines medical malpractice attorney estate plan Employment Discrimination Law rest breaks Self-Directed IRA Accounts Illinois medical malpractice claim pain and suffering Deer Park traffic accident attorney Rolling Meadows marijuana attorney field sobriety test Des Plaines drug lawyer living trust vs will medical malpractice claims living trust Deer Park real estate law firm Rolling Meadows car accident lawyers accidental death benefits Des Plaines DUI attorney Des Plaines Traffic Lawyer natural gas explosion Illinois personal injury lawyers Thanksgiving healthcare Illinois traffic attorneys Des Plaines insurance attorney Illinois Sales Representative Act Illinois criminal defense attorney commercial leases Arlington Heights car accident lawyer employment law Barrington medical malpractice lawyers rollover accidents appealing an insurance claim Rolling Meadows life insurance claim denial attorney drug crimes Illinois Exclusions boating DUI Illinois living will construction accidents Arlington Heights tax lawyer insurance attorney traffic laws Palatine personal injury lawyer mortgage rent to own real estate contracts Inverness real estate attorney BAIID DGAA truck collisions Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyers income distribution deducation low-ball insurance settlement Illinois workplace discrimination attorney Rolling Meadows Traffic Lawyer fiduciary rule Palatine civil litigation lawyer Illinois estate planning law firm Buffalo Grove real estate attorney Crystal lake insurance dispute attorney Palatine injury attorney cell phone tower data personal injury accidents traffic accidents fiduciary rule delay beneficiary complications Barrington boating accident attorney insurance negligence car crashes Rolling Meadows business lawyer Inverness personal injury attorney Deer Park medical malpractice attorney Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act corporate law Illinois insurance disputes marijuana crimes attorney Illinois traffic accident lawyer Rolling Meadows personal injury lawyer Home Remodeling Repair Act Do Not Resuscitate Crystal Lake law firm Schaumburg real estate lawyer criminal Barrington estate planning attorney defective products insurance claim dispute attorney traffic crimes comp time Illinois tax attorney estate planning, death tax, succession plans, business estate plans, Barrington estate planning lawyers PTSD Joliet general practice lawyers Buffalo Grove personal injury attorney personal injury attorney Illinois home inspection Kenilworth estate planning lawyer federal regulations for LLCs cell phone accidents Deer Park workers compensation lawyer trauma after an accident power of attorney for healthcare reckless homicide slip and fall Illinois estate planning Deer Park traffic lawyer whistleblower protections Barrington attorney cell phone Crystal Lake medical malpractice law firm Chicago lawyer llinois Real Estate Lawyers Association how to avoid common denials of life insurance claims loss of consortium problem employees compensatory time liability Crystal Lake will lawyer preventable medical errors life insurance lawyer involuntary manslaughter Inverness traffic law firm Illinois boating accident lawyer Palatine punch death consent to a search construction contracts independent contractor pedestrian accident digital media accounts, estate planning, Arlington Heights estate planning attorney, wage theft Deer Park criminal attorney Crystal Lake bike accident lawyer overtime pay driving traffic violations Arlington Heights criminal lawyer overtime violations Schaumburg employment attorney Deer Park motorcycle accident lawyer Schaumburg criminal attorney college kids murder defense DUI penalities wills and trusts estate attorney Des Plaines collections attorney Palatine law firm traffic violations defense Buffalo Grove probate lawyer digital assets BAC medication errors Inverness insurance attorney real estate contract breathalyzer test Illinois DUI attorney license suspension Illinois will lawyer Schaumburg probate attorney Rolling Meadows boating crash lawyer job lawyers Arlington Heights traffic attorney trucking accident lawyers Illinois employment attorneys murder insurance denial appeals personal injury Crystal Lake personal injury attorney tax attorney Illinois medical malpractice attorney Rolling Meadows drug defense attorney Illinois personal injury Buffalo Grove criminal defense lawyer pregnant women right to work home inspection lawyer pedestrian injuries, pedestrian fatality Illinois wills and trusts Class A misdemeanor bicycle dooring accidents Fourth of July auto accidents eluding a police officer child safety distracted driving accidents Schaumburg personal injury attorney Buffalo Grove corporate attorney condo association Schaumburg employment law attorneys privacy laws insurance claim dealing with problem employees unpaid assessment pet law commercial leasing Kenilworth estate planning attorneys license revocation Crystal Lake employment law attorney Illinois injury lawyer Illinois defective products attorney Kenilworth estate planning attorney Crystal Lake traffic attorney Schaumburg criminal law attorney landlord Deer Park employment law attorney motorcycle accident Mount Prospect real estate lawyer car accident lawyer insurance claim dispute installment contracts license reinstatement Crystal Lake insurance lawyer Illinois rollover accident lawyers Arlington Heights injury attorney Des Plaines civil attorney Illinois construction accident attorney insurance claims workplace sexual harassment investment property lapse in policy rumble strips Barrington litigation attorney agent Illinois estate planning attorney health insurance dispute Whistleblower Claims life insurance claim denial, denial of life insurance claim drug crimes lawyer real estate attorneys South Barrington real estate attorney capital gains tax Crystal Lake criminal defense attorney Crystal Lake estate planning lawyer breach of contract vacation home fines Arlington Heights employment law attorneys Legal Info Palatine traffic accidents Colin Gilbert Barrington criminal defense lawyer denial of insurance claim Palatine corporate attorney Family Medical Leave Act Illinois wrongful termination lawyer Illinois employment law Barrington workers compensation attorney car crash injuries deadly crashes brain injury real estate attorney meal breaks Buffalo Grove injury lawyer Illinois personal injury lawyer Illinois trucking safety living wills DNR Schaumburg civil litigation attorney Illinois traffic laws Illinois employment laws owner responsibility startup company Schaumburg insurance claim denial Illinois law golf accidents Rolling Meadows corporate lawyer School Visitation Rights Act underinsured motorist medical marijuana slip and fall accidents manufacturing Schaumburg life insurance attorney life insurance claims pay when paid contract Des Plaines personal injury lawyers Mt Prospect Attorney Illinois employment lawyer business litigation Illinois employment law attorneys subcontractor wills caregiver Mount Prospect elder law attorney Arlington Heights pedestrian accidents Palatine real estate lawyer Illinois Probate Act of 1975 Long Grove real estate attorney Illinois insurance claim attorney Palatine drug lawyer Inverness real estate lawyer irrevocable trust nursing home negligence Palatine corporate law attorneys comparative negligence Palatine elder law attorney deed transfer Barrington business law firm employment law, Illinois employment laws car accident Illinois elder law attorney Deer Park personal injury lawyer commercial real estate ACA mass shooting insurance claim delay Illinois medical malpractice lawyers criminal law Illinois medical malpractice case Illinois mortgages motorcycle accident lawyer Illinois wills and trusts attorneys murder charges advance healthcare directive digital information food poisoning POA Barrington drug crime attorney DUI Schaumburg wrongful death attorney vacation home Crystal Lake pedestrian accident lawyer employment contract, employment law, employment at-will, Deer Park employment law attorneys, contract, Schaumburg Attorney suspended license Barrington employment law attorney Long Grove wills and trusts attorneys blended families Landlord Tenant Ordinance Arlington Heights Attorney Rolling Meadows insurance dispute lawyers, insurance dispute crossover accidents estate planning lawyer bike accident workers compensation Palatine construction attorney sole proprietorship